The deck opens with a title slide and then an overview of the firm's capital and liquidity position after the quarter's actions. A second overview covers the franchise, the S&P downgrade, and short-seller criticism. The capital adequacy section follows, covering capital raised in 2008, growth in total equity, and a shrinking balance sheet, including reductions in high-risk fixed income positions. A leverage section compares net leverage with peers over time. A capital section explains the three measures the firm uses to judge equity adequacy and compares its CSE ratios with rival banks. The liquidity section covers the projected record liquidity pool, changes in secured funding, and a comparison with Bear Stearns. A client franchise section then addresses market share in origination and trading. Sections on the S&P downgrade and on short sellers come next, and the deck closes with a summary of the firm's resilience. Single large charts and clear three-column comparisons, such as the three capital measures on slide 10 and the peer leverage lines on slide 9, carry key points.
Slides worth studying
- Slide 10: Three side-by-side columns with matching headers and a single result box under each make the three capital measures easy to compare.
- Slide 9: Two stacked line charts with peer averages let the reader see the leverage trend at a glance.
- Slide 7: A clean table paired with two bar charts shows the balance sheet reduction in a direct before-and-after form.
Questions about this deck
How many slides does the Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. Capital Adequacy & Liquidity Update deck have?
The deck has 27 slides, according to its page count. It opens with a title slide and closes with a summary of the firm's resilience.
What does the Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. deck say about capital raised in 2008?
Slide 5 states that Lehman raised $6 billion of capital in Q2 and $7.9 billion in 2008. It includes a $4.0 B convertible preferred stock issued in April 2008, which was more than three times oversubscribed.
What does the Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. deck say about its liquidity pool?
Slide 14 projects ending the quarter with a record liquidity pool of approximately $45 billion and a record cash capital surplus of $14 billion. Slide 2 states the liquidity pool was up from $34 billion in Q1 '08.
What does the Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. deck say about the S&P downgrade?
Slide 23 says S&P downgraded Lehman Brothers' long-term credit rating to 'A' from 'A+' while affirming its short-term rating of 'A-1'. The slide states that funding is unaffected and that the impact on collateralization is minimal, with an extra $200 million in additional required collateral to support derivatives trades.
Details
- Company: Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc.
- Year: 2008
- Type: Investor presentation
- Industry: Investment banking
- Pages: 27
Review score: 6 out of 10, Needs substantial work
Presentation quality, judged with the SlideDeck Co review heuristic. Ask, evidence and idea merit are not rated here.
The route is clear and well sequenced: an opening summary on slide 2, then capital, leverage, liquidity, franchise, the S&P downgrade and short sellers, with an action-title sentence on most content slides (for example 7, 9 and 10). The core argument can be followed and the three-column layout on slide 10 and the single charts on slides 7 and 9 communicate well. Execution weakens it: the opening and closing slides are dense text with large empty areas (2, 3, 23, 26, 27), several slides rely on small tables or bar labels that would be hard to read in a room (12, 15, 16, 21), slide 19 is rotated sideways, and the closing slides offer a bullet list rather than a clear summary visual. The grayscale charts lean on shading that is hard to tell apart (slides 7, 8, 11) and slide 24 runs text into the footer, so the deck is usable as a reading document but needs substantial revision as a presentation.
Worth keeping: Keep the action-title sentence under each headline, the three-column framework on slide 10, and the large single-message charts such as the peer leverage lines on slide 9.
Most useful repair: Fix the rotated slide 19 and the text that collides with the footer on slide 23, enlarge or simplify the small tables on slides 15, 16 and 21, and make the shaded bar series distinguishable.
What would change the score: Turn the text-only opening overview and closing summary into short, structured pages with the key figures (12.1x, 16.7%, $45 billion) shown large, and cut the footer clutter and watermark text.
Confidence medium. 27 of 27 pages inspected on contact sheets, 4 at readable size. Reviewed 2026-11-09. Model-assisted review (claude-sonnet-5-5).
Full text of the slides (27 slides)
Every slide's words and a description of its charts and images, so the deck can be searched and rebuilt. Also available as Markdown.
Slide 1
Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com). Please register to remove this message. / LEHMAN BROTHERS / June 4, 2008 / Capital Adequacy & Liquidity Update / Confidential Presentation / FOIA CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT REQUESTED / BY LEHMAN BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC. / LBHI_SEC07940_513590
Visuals: One abstract illustration: a rectangular, boxed (not full-bleed, not cropped) image of intersecting curved bands made of fine dense line-hatching, like a moire or wireframe pattern. The bands sweep diagonally from lower left to upper right and curve across the upper middle, with brighter white-grey ridges against a dark charcoal-grey ground. Lighting is even, with brighter highlights along the central band. Dominant colours are charcoal grey #3A3A3A, mid grey #7A7A7A and light grey-white #D0D0D0. No overlay or tint. The image is a flat rectangle with sharp corners and no border.
Slide 2
Overview
Despite a forecast loss in Q2 '08, the actions taken by Lehman in the quarter will result in the strongest capital and liquidity positions the Firm has ever had
◆ The issuance of $4.0 billion of convertible preferred in April and $2.0 billion of subordinated debt in May, combined with the active de-leveraging and de-risking of the balance sheet (approximately $140 billion reduction in gross and almost $70 billion reduction in net assets), combine to drive very strong forecasted capital ratios
– Net leverage of 12.1x, down from 15.4x in Q1 '08
– CSE Capital Ratio of 16.7%, up from 15.5% in Q1 '08
– Tier 1 Capital Ratio of 11.1%, up from 10.3% in Q1'08
– Surplus over Lehman's internal equity allocation model of 16.3% ($4.4bn) in Q2 '08
◆ Liquidity Pool stands at a record $45 billion (up from $34 billion in Q1 '08)
– Increased coverage of short-term debt to 1.3x, up from 1.0x in Q1 '08
– Cash Capital Surplus estimated to be at $14 billion
LEHMAN BROTHERS
1
FOIA CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT REQUESTED / BY LEHMAN BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC.
LBHI_SEC07940_513591
Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com). Please register to remove this message.
Visuals: None. The slide contains no charts, tables, photographs, diagrams or icons. A small empty rectangular outline (missing-glyph box) sits at the top-right end of the title rule.
Slide 3
Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com). Please register to remove this message.
Overview
Lehman's core underlying franchise remains as strong as ever
Gaining market share in Investment Banking
Sales credits in Fixed Income remain strong; only down 3% in Q2 '08 vs. Q1 '08
Investment Management Division is performing well
Hedge ineffectiveness experienced in Q2 '08 is technical in nature and is not expected to drive future results
De-leveraging in Q2 '08 is a contributing factor in explaining results, but de-risking is appropriate
Impact of S&P long-term rating downgrade from 'A+' to 'A' is limited and does not adequately reflect Lehman's strong liquidity and capital positions, balance sheet improvement and underlying franchise strength
Lehman's funding ability is unaffected by the downgrade
No triggers in borrowing agreements that would cause Lehman to lose cash
Impact on collateralization is minimal, with an extra $200 million in additional collateral required to support derivatives trades
Recent criticisms of Lehman Brothers by short sellers such as David Einhorn are opportunistic and do not accurately reflect the Firm's current situation
Arguments are based on faulty analysis of Lehman's Q1 '08 marks and 10-Q filing
The shorts also do not take the following into consideration in their analysis:
Significant reduction in Lehman's exposure to high-risk assets in Q2
Capital raises which will result in the strongest leverage, liquidity and capital positions that Lehman has ever had as a public company
Continued momentum in Lehman's core underlying client franchise
LEHMAN BROTHERS
2
FOIA CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT REQUESTED BY LEHMAN BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC.
LBHI_SEC07940_513592
Slide 4
Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com). Please register to remove this message. / Capital Adequacy / FOIA CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT REQUESTED / BY LEHMAN BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC. / LBHI_SEC07940_513593
Visuals: A single horizontal black rule (about 0.3% of slide height thick) spanning from about x 8.5% to x 90%, ending in a solid black vertical bar at the right end (about 1% wide, 6% tall) beside the label. No photographs, charts, logos or icons. The rule and bar are the only graphic elements.
Slide 5
$6 billion of Capital Raised in Q2 and $7.9 billion in 2008…
Lehman’s ability to raise substantial amounts of capital in 2008 conveys a positive story / about the Firm’s access to funding as well as the market’s view of Lehman’s / creditworthiness
$4.0 B Convertible / Preferred Stock
Issued in April 2008
Non-Cumulative Dividends at 7.25%, Perpetual
Initial Conversion Rate 20.0509 per share, equivalent to $49.87 strike per share
Deeply Subordinated and senior only to Common Equity
Included as CSE Equivalent Tier 1 Capital
More than three times oversubscribed
Issued in May 2008
Coupon of 7.50%, 30-year maturity
Subordinate to Senior Debt
Included as CSE Equivalent Tier 2 Capital
$4.0 billion of orders within one hour
$2.0 B Subordinated / Debt
Issued in February 2008
Non-Cumulative Dividends at 7.95%, Perpetual
Includes Greenshoe of ~$250 million
Deeply Subordinated and senior only to Common Equity
Included as CSE Equivalent Tier 1 Capital
$1.9 B Preferred Stock
LEHMAN BROTHERS
3
FOIA CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT REQUESTED / BY LEHMAN BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC.
LBHI_SEC07940_513594
Visuals: Three dark grey pentagonal arrow (chevron-tipped) label blocks with white-on-grey stippled text: '$4.0 B Convertible Preferred Stock' (top band), '$2.0 B Subordinated Debt' (middle band), '$1.9 B Preferred Stock' (bottom band). The arrows point right toward the bullet lists. No chart, table, photograph or logo other than the text wordmark.
Slide 6
…Has Resulted In a Solid Capital Base…
Lehman was quick to respond to market demand by raising equity capital via hybrid issuances when markets were opportune
Total Equity Capital
S millions
$30,000
29,696
$24,000
23,340
4,976
4,977
$18,000
18,567
2,738
15,564
2,026
$12,000
10,923
12,636
1,310
1,000
2006
2007
2003
2004
2005
1Q'08 Proforma
$6,000
$0
8,568
10,291
12,443
14,734
17,268
17,727
Tangible Common Equity
Preferred Equity
Junior Subdebt
1. Includes $4.0bn of preferred issuance
LEHMAN BROTHERS
4
FOIA CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT REQUESTED
BY LEHMAN BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC.
LBHI_SEC07940_513595
Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com). Please register to remove this message.
Visuals: Stacked column chart. Title: Total Equity Capital, shown as white serif text on a dark grey banner. Y-axis labelled S millions, from $0 to $30,000, with gridlines and labels at $6,000, $12,000, $18,000, $24,000 and $30,000. X-axis categories: 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 1Q'08 Proforma. Three stacked series, bottom to top: Tangible Common Equity (dark charcoal, white labels): 2003 8,568; 2004 10,291; 2005 12,443; 2006 14,734; 2007 17,268; 1Q'08 Proforma 17,727. Preferred Equity (mid grey dotted fill, labels faint and partly obscured): 2003 about 1,045; 2004 about 1,345; 2005 about 1,096; 2006 about 1,098; 2007 about 1,095; 1Q'08 Proforma about 6,993. Junior Subdebt (light grey dotted fill, dark labels): 2003 1,310; 2004 1,000; 2005 2,026; 2006 2,738; 2007 4,977; 1Q'08 Proforma 4,976. Totals printed above each column in bold: 10,923; 12,636; 15,564; 18,567; 23,340; 29,696. Legend centred below the x-axis with a square swatch for each series: dark square for Tangible Common Equity, mid-grey dotted square for Preferred Equity, light dotted square for Junior Subdebt. Footnote marked 1 on the 1Q'08 Proforma axis label refers to 1. Includes $4.0bn of preferred issuance. No highlighted points. A small empty box glyph sits at top right beside the rule.
Slide 7
...As Well As Shrinkage of the Balance Sheet…
Net balance sheet (primarily inventory) is expected to be almost $70 billion lower than / Q1 '08, and gross balance sheet almost $140 billion lower
Gross and Net Balance Sheet
$ billions
Actual
Q4' 07
Actual
Q1' 08
Estimated
Q2 '08
Estimated Reduction
Q2 '08 vs. Q1 '08
Net Assets
373
397
330
(67)
Gross Assets
691
786
648
(138)
Leveragable Equity
23
26
27
Gross and Net Leverage Ratios
16.1x
15.4x
12.1x
30.7x
31.7x
24.6x
LEH
LEH
Q4 2007
Q1 2008
Q2 2008 Projection
LEHMAN BROTHERS
5
FOIA CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT REQUESTED / BY LEHMAN BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC.
LBHI_SEC07940_513596
Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com). Please register to remove this message.
Visuals: Chart: clustered vertical bar chart titled 'Gross and Net Leverage Ratios' with two groups, each labelled 'LEH' beneath the bars. Series: Q4 2007 (dark grey hatched bars), Q1 2008 (white bars with thin black outline), Q2 2008 Projection (light grey dotted bars). Group 1 values: Q4 2007 16.1x, Q1 2008 15.4x, Q2 2008 Projection 12.1x. Group 2 values: Q4 2007 30.7x, Q1 2008 31.7x, Q2 2008 Projection 24.6x. No y-axis, units or gridlines are printed; the baseline is a thin dotted line. Legend below the chart with square swatches matching the series fills. No highlighted points. Table: 'Gross and Net Balance Sheet' with columns $ billions, Actual Q4' 07, Actual Q1' 08, Estimated Q2 '08, Estimated Reduction Q2 '08 vs. Q1 '08. Rows: Net Assets 373, 397, 330, (67); Gross Assets 691, 786, 648, (138); Leveragable Equity 23, 26, 27, no value in reduction column. Lehman Brothers wordmark is set as text, not an image.
Slide 8
...Including Positions in High-Risk Assets
Lehman Brothers is on track to reduce the Firm’s key Risk positions in the Fixed Income arena
High Yield Acq Financing
$ billions
25
20
15
10
5
0
23.9
Unfunded/ Contingent
12.4
17.8
Unfunded/ Contingent
5.9
-34%
11.8
2.6
Funded 11.5
Funded 11.9
Funded 9.2
4Q07
1Q08
Forecast 2Q08
Commercial Mortgages
$ billions
40
30
20
10
0
-20%
29.0
4Q07
1Q08
Forecast 2Q08
Residential Mortgages
$ billions
40
30
20
10
0
-19%
25.6
4Q07
1Q08
Forecast 2Q08
♦ Steady progress in selling/syndicating
♦ Non-traditional buyers account for 73% of sales in 2008
♦ Sales have been focused on largest exposures
♦ Includes whole loans & securities in ~ 40: 60 proportion
LEHMAN BROTHERS
6
FOIA CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT REQUESTED BY LEHMAN BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC.
LBHI_SEC07940_513597
Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com). Please register to remove this message.
Visuals: Three vertical bar charts, each with a $ billions y-axis and category labels 4Q07, 1Q08 and Forecast 2Q08. Chart 1, High Yield Acq Financing: y-axis 0 to 25 in steps of 5. Stacked bars: 4Q07 total 23.9 with Funded 11.5 (dark grey) and Unfunded/Contingent 12.4 (white box with thin black outline); 1Q08 total 17.8 with Funded 11.9 and Unfunded/Contingent 5.9; Forecast 2Q08 total 11.8 with Funded 9.2 (light grey stipple) and a 2.6 box above it. A dashed-outline callout -34% with a black arrow runs from the 1Q08 bar toward the forecast bar. Chart 2, Commercial Mortgages: y-axis 0 to 40 in steps of 10; single bars 4Q07 about 39, 1Q08 about 36, Forecast 2Q08 29.0 (light grey stipple); callout -20% in a dotted box with arrow to 29.0. Chart 3, Residential Mortgages: y-axis 0 to 40 in steps of 10; bars 4Q07 about 32, 1Q08 about 32, Forecast 2Q08 25.6 (light grey stipple); callout -19% in a dotted box with arrow to 25.6. Bars are dark grey hatched #3A3A3A for actuals and light grey stipple #C8C8C8 for forecast. Faint dotted horizontal gridlines #BBBBBB. No legend.
Slide 9
Leverage At Historically Low Levels
Lehman will end Q2 '08 with the lowest net leverage ratio in its history as a public company
Lehman versus Peers Net Leverage¹
25.0x / 20.0x / 15.0x / 10.0x
Q4 '94 / Q4 '95 / Q4 '96 / Q4 '97 / Q4 '98 / Q4 '99 / Q4 '00 / Q4 '01 / Q4 '02 / Q4 '03 / Q4 '04 / Q4 '05 / Q4 '06 / Q4 '07 / Q1 '08 / Q2 '08 est
LEH / Peer Avg
Lehman versus Peers Gross Leverage¹
35.0x / 30.0x / 25.0x / 20.0x / 15.0x
Q4 '94 / Q4 '95 / Q4 '96 / Q4 '97 / Q4 '98 / Q4 '99 / Q4 '00 / Q4 '01 / Q4 '02 / Q4 '03 / Q4 '04 / Q4 '05 / Q4 '06 / Q4 '07 / Q1 '08 / Q2 '08 est
LEH / Peer Avg
1. Peers include GS, MER, MS & BSC.
LEHMAN BROTHERS
7
FOIA CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT REQUESTED / BY LEHMAN BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC.
LBHI_SEC07940_513598
Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com). Please register to remove this message.
Visuals: Two line charts stacked vertically. Chart 1: 'Lehman versus Peers Net Leverage' (footnote 1), y-axis net leverage in multiples (x) from 10.0x to 25.0x with gridlines at 10.0x, 15.0x, 20.0x, 25.0x; x-axis quarters Q4 '94 to Q2 '08 est, one tick per quarter. Series LEH (dark line with small square markers), about values: Q4 '94 19.0x, Q4 '95 17.5x, Q4 '96 20.5x, Q4 '97 21.5x, Q4 '98 18.0x, Q4 '99 15.8x, Q4 '00 14.7x, Q4 '01 15.8x, Q4 '02 15.0x, Q4 '03 15.0x, Q4 '04 13.8x, Q4 '05 13.6x, Q4 '06 14.6x, Q4 '07 16.1x, Q1 '08 15.5x, Q2 '08 est 12.1x. Series Peer Avg (light grey dotted line, small markers), about values: Q4 '99 13.7x, Q4 '00 12.8x, Q4 '01 13.2x, Q4 '02 12.8x, Q4 '03 12.4x, Q4 '04 13.3x, Q4 '05 13.8x, Q4 '06 14.5x, Q4 '07 18.1x, Q1 '08 17.4x; no Peer Avg point before Q4 '99. Legend below chart 1: LEH and Peer Avg. Chart 2: 'Lehman versus Peers Gross Leverage' (footnote 1), y-axis gross leverage from 15.0x to 35.0x with gridlines at 15.0x, 20.0x, 25.0x, 30.0x, 35.0x; same x-axis quarters. Series LEH, about values: Q4 '94 32.7x, Q4 '95 31.4x, Q4 '96 33.3x, Q4 '97 33.5x, Q4 '98 28.4x, Q4 '99 30.7x, Q4 '00 29.0x, Q4 '01 29.4x, Q4 '02 29.2x, Q4 '03 23.6x, Q4 '04 24.1x, Q4 '05 24.6x, Q4 '06 26.2x, Q4 '07 31.0x, Q1 '08 31.9x, Q2 '08 est 24.8x. Series Peer Avg, about values: Q4 '99 25.9x, Q4 '00 22.8x, Q4 '01 23.8x, Q4 '02 23.0x, Q4 '03 22.2x, Q4 '04 23.9x, Q4 '05 25.3x, Q4 '06 26.9x, Q4 '07 31.4x, Q1 '08 31.0x. Legend below chart 2: LEH and Peer Avg. No highlighted points. Plain black-and-grey line chart with no fills.
Slide 10
Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com). Please register to remove this message. / Despite Anticipated Loss, Lehman Is Strongly Capitalized / As a result of the combined impact of Lehman's capital raising and deleveraging, / Lehman is currently well-capitalized by three key measures / To monitor equity adequacy the Firm uses three measures: Net Leverage, CSE Capital Ratios and our internal Equity / Adequacy Framework (EAF) / Net Leverage / CSE Capital Ratios / Equity Adequacy Framework / Accounting ratio that measures the value of assets supported by $1 of equity / Does not account for different risk/liquidity characteristics of assets / Heavily quoted by journalists and analysts / Measures by which regulators determine whether a bank is adequately capitalized / Tier 1 and Total Capital Ratio / Account for on- and off-balance sheet assets with different risk profiles / Will begin reporting externally in Q2 '08 / Multi-factor model that determines the Gross Equity (Common Equity + Hybrid Equity) requirement / Additive charges for Trading, Counterparty, Operational, Liquidity, and Corp Assets / Accounts for on and off-balance sheet assets with different risk profiles / Liquidity component will be charged to businesses / Q2 '08 Estimate / Net Leverage = 12.1x / Tier 1 Ratio = 11.1%1 / Total Capital Ratio = 16.7% / Surplus = $4.4 billion / (16.3% of gross equity required) / 1. Updated for approved SEC Methodology. If FV gains on debt are excluded from capital then Q2'08 ratios would be 10.5% Tier 1 and 15.8% Total Capital / LEHMAN BROTHERS / 8 / FOIA CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT REQUESTED BY LEHMAN BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC. / LBHI_SEC07940_513599
Visuals: Three grey textured header bars sit above three columns with bullet text; below each column a downward-pointing outlined triangle (chevron-like V shape, thin dark outline, white fill) points to a rounded rectangle outlined in thin black: Net Leverage = 12.1x; Tier 1 Ratio = 11.1% with superscript 1 and Total Capital Ratio = 16.7%; Surplus = $4.4 billion (16.3% of gross equity required). Vertical black rules separate the columns. No photographs or charts.
Slide 11
CSE Capital Ratios Strong
The Firm has made a conscious decision to shore up its capital base and maintain a Total Capital ratio under the CSE regime above that of the major Commercial Banks' equivalent Total Capital Ratio under Basel
Consolidated Supervised Entity (CSE)
The Firm must maintain a minimum “Total Risk-Based Capital Ratio”, as defined as allowable capital divided by risk weighted assets, of 10.0%
Allowable capital consists of common equity, perpetual preferred stock, and hybrids/ subordinated debt subject to certain thresholds and restrictions less deductions (e.g. Goodwill, DTA, and other)
Risk-weighted assets are principally driven by market risk, credit risk and operational risk allowances computed using methodologies developed by the Company and approved by the SEC.
Total Capital and Tier 1 Ratios1
18%
16%
14%
12%
10%
8%
6%
4%
2%
0%
LEH Q2 '08 Forecast
LEH 2 Q1 '08
CS
JPM
WB
BAC
DB
C
Total Capital Ratio
Tier 1
16.7%
15.5%
13.6%
12.5%
12.1%
11.7%
11.6%
11.2%
11.1%
10.3%
9.8%
8.3%
7.4%
7.5%
9.2%
7.7%
1. All Banks' ratios are as of Q1 '08 per their Earnings press releases
2. Updated for approved SEC Methodology. If FV gains on debt are excluded from capital then Q2'08 ratios would be 10.5% Tier 1 and 15.8% Total Capital
LEHMAN BROTHERS
9
FOIA CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT REQUESTED / BY LEHMAN BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC.
LBHI_SEC07940_513600
Visuals: Clustered vertical bar chart titled 'Total Capital and Tier 1 Ratios' (superscript 1). Y axis: 0% to 18% in 2% steps, percentage. X axis: categories LEH Q2 '08 Forecast, LEH 2 Q1 '08, CS, JPM, WB, BAC, DB, C. Series 1 'Total Capital Ratio' light grey hatched bars: LEH Q2 '08 16.7%, LEH Q1 '08 15.5%, CS 13.6%, JPM 12.5%, WB 12.1%, BAC 11.7%, DB 11.6%, C 11.2%. Series 2 'Tier 1' dark grey hatched bars: LEH Q2 '08 11.1%, LEH Q1 '08 10.3%, CS 9.8%, JPM 8.3%, WB 7.4%, BAC 7.5%, DB 9.2%, C 7.7%. Each bar carries its value label above it. Legend is boxed with a dotted border at bottom right of the chart, showing a light grey hatched square for Total Capital Ratio and a dark grey hatched square for Tier 1. Horizontal dotted gridlines at each 2% step. No highlighted points. A small empty rectangle glyph (missing character box) sits at the top right of the title rule. No photographs, logos or icons apart from the Lehman Brothers wordmark.
Slide 12
Capital Raising More than Enough to Offset Lower Earnings / The Firm has proactively raised capital when markets were opportune and has adequate / capital to cover depressed earnings during the current downturn / Capital Raised versus Retained Earnings and Other Comprehensive Income Q3 '07 to Q1 '08 1 / $ billions / $50 / 1 to 1 / $40 / C / $30 / UBS / Capital Raised / $20 / BAC / MER / $10 / LEH / JPM / MS / $0 / CS / DB / GS / ($50) / ($40) / ($30) / ($20) / ($10) / $0 / $10 / $20 / $30 / Retained Earnings & Other Comprehensive Income / 1. Includes equity raised through 5/30/08 / LEHMAN BROTHERS / 10 / FOIA CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT REQUESTED / BY LEHMAN BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC. / LBHI_SEC07940_513601
Visuals: Chart: scatter plot titled 'Capital Raised versus Retained Earnings and Other Comprehensive Income Q3 '07 to Q1 '08 (footnote 1)'. Y axis labelled 'Capital Raised' in $ billions, range $0 to $50, gridlines every $10. X axis labelled 'Retained Earnings & Other Comprehensive Income' in $ billions, range ($50) to $30, labelled every $10, with tick labels ($50), ($40), ($30), ($20), ($10), $0, $10, $20, $30. Single series of ten labelled points, values about: C at x about ($25), y about $37; UBS at x about ($44), y about $27.5; MER at x about ($19), y about $15.5; BAC at x about $5, y about $19; LEH at x about $1, y about $6; JPM at x about $6.5, y about $7.5; MS at x about ($8), y about $5; CS at x about ($15), y about $0; DB at x about $1, y about $0; GS at x about $7, y about $0. Points are small grey diamond markers. A black dashed reference line labelled '1 to 1' runs from ($50, $50) diagonally down to about ($1, $0), crossing the points. No legend. No points are highlighted in colour.
Slide 13
Liquidity / LBHI_SEC07940_513602 / FOIA CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT REQUESTED / BY LEHMAN BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC. / Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com). Please register to remove this message.
Visuals: A thin black vertical line, about 0.3% of slide width, running from just below the Liquidity heading down to about 91% of slide height, with a thick black horizontal bar about 1% of slide height tall forming a cap at its top end that extends slightly to the right of the line. No photographs, charts, logos or icons. The line and bar are the only graphic elements.
Slide 14
Building A “Liquidity Fortress”
◆ We project ending the quarter with a record liquidity pool of approximately $45 billion and a record cash capital surplus of $14 billion
◆ With only $8 billion of debt moving into current portion for the remainder of the year and with further cash inflows forecast from assets sales, there is minimal refinancing pressure
Liquidity Pool ($ billions)
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008 Q1
14-Mar
23-May
2008 Q2 (Proj.)
15.3
17.2
18.2
31.4
34.9
34.3
31.1
40.2
44.6
Cash Capital Surplus ($ billions)
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
2006 Q4
2007 Q1
2007 Q2
2007 Q3
2007 Q4
2008 Q1
14-Mar
23-May
2008 Q2 (Proj.)
6.0
5.3
2.5
8.1
8.0
7.0
5.1
7.0
14.0
LEHMAN BROTHERS
11
FOIA CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT REQUESTED / BY LEHMAN BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC.
LBHI_SEC07940_513603
Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com). Please register to remove this message.
Visuals: Two vertical bar charts. Left chart: title “Liquidity Pool ($ billions)”; y-axis 0 to 45 in steps of 5, unlabelled units shown in banner; x-axis categories 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008 Q1, 14-Mar, 23-May, 2008 Q2 (Proj.); single series of dark grey bars with labelled values 15.3, 17.2, 18.2, 31.4, 34.9, 34.3, 31.1, 40.2, 44.6. The final bar (2008 Q2 Proj.) is light grey with a fine dotted texture, marking a projection; no legend. Right chart: title “Cash Capital Surplus ($ billions)”; y-axis 0 to 16 in steps of 2; x-axis categories 2006 Q4, 2007 Q1, 2007 Q2, 2007 Q3, 2007 Q4, 2008 Q1, 14-Mar, 23-May, 2008 Q2 (Proj.); single series of dark grey bars with labelled values 6.0, 5.3, 2.5, 8.1, 8.0, 7.0, 5.1, 7.0, 14.0. The final bar is light grey dotted (projection); no legend; no highlighted points beyond the projection bar. Both charts have thin black baseline and tick marks, no gridlines. Banner headers are dark grey hatched rectangles with light text. A small outlined square glyph sits at the top right corner beside the title rule.
Slide 15
Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com). Please register to remove this message.
Reducing Liquidity Risk Of Secured Funding
◆ We have increased our overfunding from around $10-15 billion to $15-20 billion – more than half in non-Central Bank eligible collateral – primarily high yield corporates
– Including excess collateral (i.e., collateral reversed to fill repo tickets), the excess repo capacity stood at close to $30 billion on May 22 – 30% of the Firm and customer collateral funded that day
◆ We also increased the average tenor of the repo book from 20-25 days to 25-35 days (35-40 days for collateral that cannot be pledged to the Federal Reserve or the ECB)
◆ We are seeing increasing appetite for providing term funding and have raised $5 billion of additional term financing in the past few weeks
Non-Traditional 1 Repo Book Metrics
3/14 - 5/22
29-Feb / 4-Mar / 14-Mar / 2-Apr / 22-May / Change
Repo Book ($ Billions)
Excess collateral / Not available / 12.8
Firm and customer collateral / 98.9
Allocated Collateral / 116.4 / 114.0 / 115.3 / 108.3 / 111.7 / -3%
Overfunding / 9.2 / 14.6 / 12.7 / 18.0 / 17.1 / 35%
Repo Capacity / 125.6 / 128.6 / 128.0 / 126.3 / 128.8 / 1%
Excess Repo Capacity / 9.2 / 14.6 / 12.7 / 18.0 / 29.9 / N/A
Average tenor (days)
Grand Total / 25 / 22 / 24 / 25 / 33 / 38%
Central Bank Eligible Collateral / 26
Non Central Bank Eligible Collateral / 38
% Repo Book With Maturities <= 1 Week / 58% / 58% / 57% / 52% / 46% / -11%
1. Non-traditional repo book excludes Governments, Treasuries, Government/MBS Agencies and Sovereigns
LEHMAN BROTHERS
12
FOIA CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT REQUESTED / BY LEHMAN BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC.
LBHI_SEC07940_513604
Visuals: Table titled Non-Traditional 1 Repo Book Metrics in a grey hatched header bar. Columns: row labels, 29-Feb, 4-Mar, 14-Mar, 2-Apr, 22-May, and 3/14 - 5/22 Change. Rows: Excess collateral (22-May 12.8; other dates Not available, spanning the first four columns); Firm and customer collateral (22-May 98.9); Allocated Collateral (116.4, 114.0, 115.3, 108.3, 111.7, change -3%); Overfunding (9.2, 14.6, 12.7, 18.0, 17.1, change 35% boxed); Repo Capacity in bold (125.6, 128.6, 128.0, 126.3, 128.8, change 1%); Excess Repo Capacity in bold (9.2, 14.6, 12.7, 18.0, 29.9, change N/A); Average tenor (days) section with Grand Total (25, 22, 24, 25, 33, change 38% boxed), Central Bank Eligible Collateral in italics (26 on 22-May), Non Central Bank Eligible Collateral in italics (38 on 22-May); % Repo Book With Maturities <= 1 Week (58%, 58%, 57%, 52%, 46%, change -11% boxed). Thin black rules separate the header row, the Repo Book label row and the Overfunding and Grand Total blocks. Boxed changes are 35%, 38% and -11%. No chart or photograph.
Slide 16
Key Liquidity Metrics At Lehman Brothers & Bear Stearns / ◆ Lehman Brothers had stronger liquidity metrics at the end of Q1 '08 than Bear Stearns / – 60% greater balance sheet but 130% greater equity / – Bear Stearns' short-term debt stood at 1.5x its liquidity pool vs. 1.0x for Lehman Brothers / ◆ Bear Stearns had very few unencumbered assets / – Half of BSC STD was secured, which might have exacerbated the liquidity crisis in view of the exceptionally low amounts of unencumbered assets / ◆ Bear Stearns was very reliant on customer free credit balances; if it lost these, it would need to quickly create substantial secured funding capacity for equities at a time when lenders would be likely to pull away / ◆ Bear Stearns had almost no margin for error in terms of liquidity management. A reduction in short-term debt or in customer free credit balances would leave it in a precarious liquidity position / Q1 '08 Key Liquidity Metrics ($ billions) / Lehman / LEH / Bear Stearns / Brothers / BSC / Net balance sheet / 254 / 397 / 1.6x / Net Leverage / 22.6x / 15.4x / 0.7x / Liquidity pool / 17 / 34 / 2.0x / STD excluding current portion / 16 / 16 / 1.0x / Current portion of LTD / 10 / (E) / 19 / 1.9x / Total short-term debt / 26 / 35 / 1.3x / Short-term debt / Liquidity pool / 1.5x / 1.0x / 0.7x / Unencumbered assets / 14 / 161 / 11.5x / Free credit balances / 43 / 13 / 0.3x / LEHMAN BROTHERS / 13 / FOIA CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT REQUESTED / BY LEHMAN BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC. / LBHI_SEC07940_513605
Visuals: One table, no chart or images. Table 'Q1 '08 Key Liquidity Metrics ($ billions)' sits on a dark grey hatched header bar spanning the content width, with white bold text. Column headers: Bear Stearns (underlined), Lehman Brothers (underlined), LEH / BSC (underlined), all bold serif. Rows, with label then Bear Stearns, Lehman Brothers, LEH / BSC values: Net balance sheet 254, 397, 1.6x; Net Leverage 22.6x, 15.4x, 0.7x; Liquidity pool 17, 34, 2.0x; STD excluding current portion 16, 16, 1.0x; Current portion of LTD 10, 19, 1.9x with '(E)' printed between the Bear Stearns and Lehman values and thin rules above the Bear Stearns and Lehman value cells; Total short-term debt 26, 35, 1.3x; Short-term debt / Liquidity pool 1.5x, 1.0x, 0.7x; Unencumbered assets 14, 161, 11.5x; Free credit balances 43, 13, 0.3x. Values are centred under column headers. No highlighted points.
Slide 17
Recent Modifications In Funding Strategy
◆ Since last summer, when the funding and trading environment first became more challenging, we have made a series of modifications in our funding strategy in order to strengthen our liquidity
– Increased our cash surplus targets from $2-5 billion to $4-7 billion
– Front loaded our issuance program – completed our benchmark issuance plan by early May
– "Overfund" repos for harder to fund asset classes, such as high yield corporates, to mitigate risk of loss of secured funding capacity
– Increased our CP program to mitigate risk of operational friction in a very volatile environment
– Started a program to securitize illiquid assets such as corporate loans and commercial whole loans. The resulting securities, which are rated, can then be pledged to counterparties or Central Banks
– Discuss our liquidity management and position more proactively with creditors, trading counterparts, rating agencies and other stakeholders
◆ As a result, we were well prepared to face the extraordinarily difficult funding environment of the week of March 17
– Started the week with a strong liquidity position
– Entire Firm was fully engaged in defending the "Liquidity Fortress"
• Active communication with clients with quick escalation to senior management if necessary
- Lehman senior management proactively involved in calling their counterparts at key relationships to put pressure on traders who refused to trade with Lehman
• Great coordination between Front Office, Finance and Operations to minimize any operational friction
LEHMAN BROTHERS
14
FOIA CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT REQUESTED / BY LEHMAN BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC.
LBHI_SEC07940_513606
Slide 18
Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com). Please register to remove this message. / Overview of Client Franchise / FOIA CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT REQUESTED / BY LEHMAN BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC. / LBHI_SEC07940_513607
Visuals: A thin black horizontal rule runs from about 8.5% to 89% of the slide width at about 44% of the slide height, with a solid black vertical bar (about 1% wide, 6% tall) at its right end. No photographs, charts, logos or icons.
Slide 19
Core Sales Credits Are Still Strong...
Lehman's sales credits, which are the majority of the capital markets run rates (historically around 80%), have done well during the economic downturn, and have actually been less volatile during this period
◆ Lehman's sales credits in Q2 '08 were strong in a particularly difficult economic environment, down only 5% from Q1 levels, and 1% year-over-year
Sales Credits¹
Pre - Downturn
Standard Deviation = $521
Post - Downturn
Standard Deviation = $301
$ millions
$5,000 $4,500 $4,000 $3,500 $3,000 $2,500 $2,000 $1,500 $1,000 $500 $0
Q2 2006 Q3 2006 Q4 2006 Q1 2007 Q2 2007 Q3 2007 Q4 2007 Q1 2008 Q2 2008F
2,813 2,796 2,989 3,227 3,176 4,055 4,293 3,622 4,221 4,012 4,037
586 741 653 832
595 726 650 825
616 858 588 927
672 850 704 1,001
712 1,150 977 1,216
762 1,071 1,062 1,397
746 831 943 1,101
797 867 992 1,565
773 865 857 1,516
FID Equities IBD IMD Average
1. Represents Fixed Income and Equities Sales Credits as well as Investment Banking and Investment Management client revenues represent fees
LEHMAN BROTHERS
15
FOIA CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT REQUESTED
BY LEHMAN BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC.
LBHI_SEC07940_513608
Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com). Please register to remove this message.
Visuals: Chart: stacked bar chart (rendered rotated, bars run horizontally) titled Sales Credits with superscript 1, showing monthly sales credits from Q2 2006 to Q2 2008F in $ millions. Value axis labelled $ millions from $0 to $5,000 in $500 steps, with gridlines; category axis lists Q2 2006, Q3 2006, Q4 2006, Q1 2007, Q2 2007, Q3 2007, Q4 2007, Q1 2008, Q2 2008F. Each bar is stacked from FID (dark dotted fill, bottom segment), Equities (light dotted), IBD (mid-grey dotted), and IMD (dark fill, top segment). Printed segment values: Q2 2006 FID 586, Equities 741, IBD 653, IMD 832; Q3 2006 595, 726, 650, 825; Q4 2006 616, 858, 588, 927; Q1 2007 672, 850, 704, 1,001; Q2 2007 712, 1,150, 977, 1,216; Q3 2007 762, 1,071, 1,062, 1,397; Q4 2007 746, 831, 943, 1,101; Q1 2008 797, 867, 992, 1,565; Q2 2008F 773, 865, 857, 1,516. Bar totals printed at bar ends: 2,813; 2,796; 2,989; 3,227; 4,055; 4,293; 3,622; 4,221; 4,012. Average marker: short dark vertical lines with labels 3,176 (Q2 2007 area) and 4,037 (Q2 2008F area). Two curly brackets: Pre-Downturn bracket over Q2 2006 to Q2 2007 labelled Standard Deviation = $521; Post-Downturn bracket over Q3 2007 to Q2 2008F labelled Standard Deviation = $301. Legend below the chart: FID (dark swatch), Equities (light dotted swatch), IBD (grey dotted swatch), IMD (dark swatch), Average (thin dark line). Logo: LEHMAN BROTHERS wordmark in small-caps serif at lower left of content.
Slide 20
…And Lehman Gaining Market Share in A Weak Market…
We continue to increase our market share in all corners of Origination1 and Trading2 ,
highlighting the strength of our client franchise in difficult markets
Fixed Income Trading Volume (%)
13.0 12.5 12.0 11.5 11.0 10.5 10.0
12.7
12.2
11.1
2006 2007 YTD 2008
Equity Trading Volume (%)
16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0
14.6 14.3 13.2 9.1 8.4 7.8 6.6 6.5 6.0 5.7 4.0 3.3
2006 2007 YTD 2008
NYSE Nasdaq LSE TSE
M&A (%)
30 25 20 15 10 5 0
24.4 19.4 17.7 17.5 15.7 15.4
2006 2007 YTD 2008
M&A Announced M&A Completed
IBD Capital Markets (%)
7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0
6.6 5.8 5.2 4.7 4.5 4.2 4.0 3.9 3.6
2006 2007 YTD 2008
Equity and Equity Related High Grade Debt High Yield Debt
1. Thomson Financial; all data is calendar year, YTD is through May 30, 2008
2. Fixed Income - Federal Reserve; all data is fiscal year, YTD is through May 14, 2008; Equity - Applicable exchanges and Lehman Brothers; all data is calendar year, YTD is through Mar 31, 2008
LEHMAN BROTHERS
16
FOIA CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT REQUESTED / BY LEHMAN BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC.
LBHI_SEC07940_513609
Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com). Please register to remove this message.
Visuals: Four bar charts in a 2x2 grid. (1) Top-left, Fixed Income Trading Volume (%): vertical bar chart, y-axis 10.0 to 13.0 in steps of 0.5 (unitless percent), x categories 2006, 2007, YTD 2008; single series with values 2006 11.1, 2007 12.2, YTD 2008 12.7; no legend; bars dark grey for 2006 and 2007 and stippled light grey for YTD 2008; values printed above each bar. (2) Top-right, Equity Trading Volume (%): clustered vertical bars, y-axis 0 to 16 in steps of 2, categories 2006, 2007, YTD 2008; four series NYSE (dark grey), Nasdaq (mid grey), LSE (light stippled), TSE (dark charcoal). Values 2006: NYSE 5.7, Nasdaq 6.5, LSE 13.2, TSE 4.0. 2007: NYSE 6.0, Nasdaq 7.8, LSE 14.6, TSE 6.6. YTD 2008: NYSE 3.3, Nasdaq 8.4, LSE 14.3, TSE 9.1. Legend below the axis in one row: NYSE, Nasdaq, LSE, TSE. (3) Bottom-left, M&A (%): clustered vertical bars, y-axis 0 to 30 in steps of 5, categories 2006, 2007, YTD 2008; series M&A Announced (dark charcoal) and M&A Completed (stippled light grey). Values 2006: Announced 15.4, Completed 15.7. 2007: Announced 17.5, Completed 19.4. YTD 2008: Announced 17.7, Completed 24.4. Legend below: M&A Announced, M&A Completed. (4) Bottom-right, IBD Capital Markets (%): clustered vertical bars, y-axis 0 to 7 in steps of 1, categories 2006, 2007, YTD 2008; series Equity and Equity Related (dark charcoal), High Grade Debt (mid grey), High Yield Debt (stippled light grey). Values 2006: 3.9, 4.5, 5.2. 2007: 3.6, 4.0, 6.6. YTD 2008: 5.8, 4.2, 4.7. Legend below: Equity and Equity Related, High Grade Debt, High Yield Debt. No highlighted points beyond the stippled light bars. Also a small missing-glyph box (empty rectangle outline) at the far right end of the title rule. No photographs, icons or logos other than the text wordmark LEHMAN BROTHERS.
Slide 21
...With Strong Franchise Gains in Investment Banking
Lehman is achieving significant market share gains in a challenging environment
Investment Banking Market Share 1
Global / 2006 / 2007 / YTD 08
M&A Announced / 15.4% / 17.5% / 17.7%
M&A Completed / 15.7% / 19.4% / 24.4%
Equity & Equity Related / 3.9% / 3.6% / 5.8%
High Grade Debt / 4.5% / 4.0% / 4.2%
High Yield Debt / 5.2% / 6.6% / 4.7%
Franchise Momentum 1
Leadership in strategic M&A and financial sector restructuring
$4.5 billion equity and convertible preferred issuance for FNMA
$7.0 billion equity and convertible issuance for Washington Mutual
As well as issuances for CIT, AIG, MBIA and regional banks
#3 in U.S. and # 1 in Asia (ex-Japan) announced M&A
Advised on the 2 largest announced M&A transactions of the year and 3 of the top 4 completed deals
$109.0 billion Phillip Morris International spin-off
$42.0 billion hostile bid by Microsoft for Yahoo
$21.0 billion acquisition of Imperial by Altadis
$15.0 billion Sprint Nextel / Clearwire transaction
Increased focus on corporate derivatives (10% and 14% of Investment Banking revenues in FY06 and FY07, respectively)
Investment Banking Revenues
CAGR '04-'07: 21%
$2.2 / $2.9 / $3.1 / $3.9 / $3.5
0.6 / 0.6 / 0.8 / 0.8 / 0.9 / 0.8 / 1.3 / 1.0 / 1.1 / 1.1
2004 / 2005 / 2006 / 2007 / 2008 F 2
Debt / Equity / Advisory
1. Market share based on year-to-date Thomson data as of May 31, 2008
2. 2008 data actual through April and annualized thereafter
LEHMAN BROTHERS
17
FOIA CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT REQUESTED / BY LEHMAN BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC.
LBHI_SEC07940_513610
Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com). Please register to remove this message.
Visuals: Chart: stacked column chart titled Investment Banking Revenues, with years 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007 and 2008 F (footnote 2) on the category axis and no numeric value axis shown. Each column has a printed total above it: $2.2 (2004), $2.9 (2005), $3.1 (2006), $3.9 (2007), $3.5 (2008 F). Series from bottom to top: Debt (dark grey), Equity (mid grey), Advisory (light hatched grey). Printed segment values: Advisory 2004 0.6, 2005 0.8, 2006 0.9, 2007 1.3, 2008 F 1.1; Equity 2004 0.6, 2005 0.8, 2006 0.8, 2007 1.0, 2008 F 1.1; Debt values are obscured by shading, so they are about 1.0 (2004), about 1.3 (2005), about 1.4 (2006), about 1.6 (2007) and about 1.3 (2008 F). A black arrow runs diagonally from the 2004 column up to the 2007 column labelled CAGR '04-'07: 21%. Legend beneath the axis reads Debt, Equity, Advisory with small square swatches matching the series. Table: Investment Banking Market Share, columns Global, 2006, 2007, YTD 08. Rows: M&A Announced 15.4%, 17.5%, 17.7%; M&A Completed 15.7%, 19.4%, 24.4%; Equity & Equity Related 3.9%, 3.6%, 5.8%; High Grade Debt 4.5%, 4.0%, 4.2%; High Yield Debt 5.2%, 6.6%, 4.7%. Logo: LEHMAN BROTHERS wordmark in dark grey small caps serif at bottom left. Other: a small hollow rectangle outline at the far right end of the title rule.
Slide 22
Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com). Please register to remove this message. / Discussion of S&P Downgrade / FOIA CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT REQUESTED / BY LEHMAN BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC. / LBHI_SEC07940_513611
Slide 23
S&P Downgrade Reflects Industry Concerns…
On June 2, S&P reviewed the global securities industry to rassess the impact of a / protracted negative economic environment on industry credit ratings
◆ As a result of this review, S&P took the following actions:
– Downgraded Lehman Brothers’ long-term credit rating to ‘A’ from ‘A+’, while affirming its short-term credit / rating of ‘A-1’
– Ratings for Morgan Stanley and Merrill Lynch were similarly lowered one notch (to ‘A+’ and ‘A’, respectively)
– Outlooks for all three firms remained negative, while the outlooks on JPMorgan Chase and Bank of America were / downgraded from Stable to Negative
◆ Lehman Brothers’ ratings relative to most of its direct peers did not change and the downgrades primarily reflect / S&P’s concerns that the earnings capacity of “the securities industry as a whole” has deteriorated since its last / industry outlook on March 21, 2008
◆ With respect to Lehman Brothers, S&P acknowledged that:
– Up to Q1 ’08, Lehman Brothers’ performance “has held up relatively well under current market conditions”
– On its June 3 conference call, S&P noted that Lehman Brothers’ cost-cutting initiatives will positively influence / future revenues
– Lehman Brothers’ has “been bolstering its liquidity and funding profile…and continues to implement a number of / measures to ensure sound liquidity and the ability to meet funding obligations in a stressed economic / environment” as well as a contingent funding plan that S&P “considers to be sound”
– The Fed’s recent actions also “enhance the near-term funding flexibility of Lehman and its peers”
◆ The impact of S&P’s downgrade on Lehman’s funding and liquidity is limited
– Funding is unaffected
– No triggers in Lehman’s borrowing agreements that would cause the Firm to lose cash
– Impact on collateralization is minimal, with an extra $200 million in additional required collateral to support / derivatives trades
LEHMAN BROTHERS
18
FOIA CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT REQUESTED / BY LEHMAN BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC.
LBHI_SEC07940_513612
Slide 24
...But Does Not Accurately Reflect Lehman's Entire Story
While Lehman Brothers agrees with S&P's statements regarding our liquidity and / funding profile,the Firm believes that the downgrade and maintenance of a negative / outlook do not reflect or acknowledge Lehman's material improvement in a number of / areas
◆ Liquidity pool
– Lehman Brothers will close Q2 '08 with an expected liquidity pool of $45 billion, the highest that it has ever been
◆ Capital position
– Lehman Brothers has issued $7.9 billion of capital in 2008 and will close Q2 '08 with record capital ratios
– During its June 3 conference call S&P specifically referred to Lehman's capital raises and noted that "Lehman / does not have a capital issue at this time"
◆ Balance sheet contraction and deleveraging
– Lehman Brothers has significantly reduced its exposure to high-risk assets, which combined with the / abovementioned capital issuances will allow the Firm to close Q2 '08 at an all-time low for net leverage
◆ Underlying franchise strength
– Lehman Brothers' core client franchise has been resilient and the Firm has increased its market share across a / broad array of its businesses in a difficult market environment
19
LEHMAN BROTHERS
FOIA CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT REQUESTED / BY LEHMAN BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC.
LBHI_SEC07940_513613
Slide 25
Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com). Please register to remove this message. / The Impact of Short Sellers / FOIA CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT REQUESTED / BY LEHMAN BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC. / LBHI_SEC07940_513614
Slide 26
Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com). Please register to remove this message.
Opportunistic Short Sellers Ignoring the Lehman Story…
A number of short sellers (led by David Einhorn) have recently stepped up their attacks on Lehman Brothers
◆ Einhorn in particular has been aggressive in his criticism of Lehman's accounting policies and methods of valuing the assets on its balance sheet
– Recent focus has been on alleged discrepancies between figures provided during Lehman's Q1 '08 earnings call and the numbers in the Q1 '08 10-Q
◆ At the same time, the market has increasingly questioned Einhorn's motives and methods
– Buckingham Research Group noted that "these recent criticisms seem well-timed to take advantage of the market's concern around weak second-quarter results that we expect for Lehman"
– Einhorn's excessive use of the media to get his point across has also been questioned by those who claim that the current crisis is being driven by a "perceived" lack of confidence in Lehman rather than by any actual fundamental risk of default
◆ Several market commentators, including Brad Hintz at Bernstein Research, have noted that Einhorn's analysis is faulty and that they "do not believe that Lehman's Q1 '08 marks or Level 3 disclosures are materially incorrect"
– Buckingham Research Group has also stated that Einhorn's concerns are "just wrong"
LEHMAN BROTHERS
20
FOIA CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT REQUESTED BY LEHMAN BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC.
LBHI_SEC07940_513615
Slide 27
…That Highlights Lehman’s Ability to Weather The Crisis
Short sellers are completely ignoring important considerations that provide a very / different view of Lehman’s ability to weather the current economic crisis
◆ Gross writedowns are smaller than previous quarters and traded volumes suggest that support levels are strong for / high-risk asset classes, reducing the risk of further losses in the future
◆ Capital position is stronger than ever with de-levering bringing both net and gross leverage ratios to multi-year lows
◆ Liquidity position at record levels through debt and capital raises, de-levering, asset transformation, leveraging our / Banks and operational improvement
◆ Continued momentum in Lehman’s underlying client franchise that is reflected in a strong revenue run rate and / market share increases across a broad array of the Firm’s business segments
LEHMAN BROTHERS
21
FOIA CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT REQUESTED / BY LEHMAN BROTHERS HOLDINGS INC.
LBHI_SEC07940_513616
Created with novaPDF Printer (www.novaPDF.com). Please register to remove this message.
Download this deck
The hosted PDF of every library deck is free for readers of the SlideDeck Co newsletter. Join with your email and the viewer and download appear here.
Preparing a results presentation or business update of your own? The SlideDeck Co Standard Deck is a slide library for business reviews, updates and plans.






