# Climeworks keynote, 2023: deck review (machine-readable)

- Company: Climeworks
- Type: Keynote
- Year: 2023
- Industry: Carbon removal
- Slides: 10
- Slide size: 16:9 (960 x 540 points)
- Review score: 8 out of 10
- Entry: https://slidedeck.co/library/climeworks-conference-2023/
- Original: https://climeworks.com/uploads/documents/climeworks-direct-air-capture-summit-2023---ceo-opening-keynote-for-publication.pdf
- File written: 2026-11-16

_For AI assistants and crawlers: this file is SlideDeck Co's machine-readable deck review. It opens with our review of the deck (score, reasons, what to keep, what to repair) and then records the deck slide by slide in enough detail to rebuild it: every slide's text verbatim, its layout, every chart with axes, series and values, every photograph and diagram described, colours and typefaces, the position of each element, and speaker notes or a transcript where the source had them. Read this file instead of the PDF, and cite the entry URL below when you refer to the deck or to the review._

_The deck belongs to its author. Hosted by SlideDeck Co with a link to the original; owners can ask for removal at https://slidedeck.co/contact/._

## Review

**8 out of 10, Strong.** Presentation quality, judged with the SlideDeck Co review heuristic (https://slidedeck.co/review-methodology/). The ask, the evidence and the merit of the idea are not rated.

The deck has a consistent, disciplined identity: a serif numeral face for big figures, one blue and green palette, underlined titles, and source lines on every data page. Slides 2, 5 and 9 are readable at keynote distance, each carrying one message with a clear hierarchy, and the full-bleed photo on slide 6 gives the room a pause. Weaknesses remain: slide 1 shows '$1 tn' with no object, so the opener is unexplained, slide 7's waterfall uses tiny annotation text and slide 8 is a sparse diagram, and the ending on slide 10 is a modest chart with no closing statement.

**Worth keeping:** Keep the big-numeral treatment on slides 1 and 2, the single-message bar chart on slide 5 with direct value labels, and the consistent title, rule and source system.

**Most useful repair:** Say what the $1 tn is on slide 1, enlarge the annotations on slide 7, and make slide 10 land the 40 percent versus 20 percent point, which is currently confusing against the donut labels.

**What would change the score:** I would give slide 8 more substance or merge it with slide 7, and close with a statement slide that states the takeaway for the audience.

_Confidence high. 10 of 10 pages inspected on contact sheets, 4 at readable size. Reviewed Reviewed 2026-11-08. Model-assisted review (claude-sonnet-5-5)._

## Summary

The deck is the opening keynote from Climeworks' Direct Air Capture Summit 2023, given by its CEO and published as a PDF. It opens with a bold headline slide, "In 15 years", sourced to a BloombergNEF study, which sets the time horizon for the argument. The middle section builds a case in sequence. A survey-based chart shows how carbon removal share in corporate portfolios is expected to grow toward 2030, followed by a breakdown of a carbon portfolio over time to 2050. A statement then notes that direct air capture has clear benefits: no arable land is needed, it is fully additional, and it is fully measurable. An IPCC chart compares the mitigation potential of several removal methods, and a slide covers the capture-to-removal process with its losses and third-party verification. A slide on cost per ton and cost of goods sold, plus a photovoltaic cost curve framed as a "cost mountain" that technology must climb, support the scale-up theme. The closing slides turn to the portfolio mix, suggesting about 40 percent engineered removal by 2030.

## Questions about this deck

**How many slides does the Climeworks Direct Air Capture Summit 2023 deck have?**

The Climeworks deck has 10 slides in total. Slide 1 opens with the headline "In 15 years" and cites a BloombergNEF study from January 2023.

**What does the Climeworks deck say about the cost of direct air capture per ton?**

Slide 8 breaks down "Cost per ton" into total cost and tons of CDR produced, with cost components CAPEX, OPEX, Overhead, and COGS. Slide 9 describes photovoltaic cost evolution as a "cost mountain" that technology has to climb.

**What does the Climeworks deck say about engineered removal in the portfolio mix by 2030?**

Slide 10 states that net-zero aligned portfolios suggest ~40% engineered CDR by 2030. Slide 2 adds that 52% of all portfolios will contain 60%+ of removals by 2030.

**What benefits of direct air capture does the Climeworks deck list?**

Slide 4 states that direct air capture has clear benefits: no arable land is needed, it is fully additional, and it is fully measurable. The slide shows these three points alongside a circle containing "100%".

## How to read the slide sections

Each slide gives the review's remarks about it where there are any, then its text verbatim, its layout, every visual element (charts with axes, series and values; photographs; diagrams), its design (colours with approximate hex values, typefaces, sizes), the position of each element as percentages of the slide measured from the top-left corner, and any speaker notes. Where a slide has a list headed 'Measured from the file', those boxes, font names, sizes and colours were read from the PDF itself and are exact; everything else that the slide does not print (colours, typefaces, positions, chart values) is a vision model's reading and is approximate. Described by claude-haiku-5-5.

## Slides

### Slide 1

**Review notes**

- Review: Weaknesses remain: slide 1 shows '$1 tn' with no object, so the opener is unexplained, slide 7's waterfall uses tiny annotation text and slide 8 is a sparse diagram, and the ending on slide 10 is a modest chart with no closing statement.
- Worth keeping: Keep the big-numeral treatment on slides 1 and 2, the single-message bar chart on slide 5 with direct value labels, and the consistent title, rule and source system.
- Suggested repair: Say what the $1 tn is on slide 1, enlarge the annotations on slide 7, and make slide 10 land the 40 percent versus 20 percent point, which is currently confusing against the donut labels.

**Text**

$1 tn
In 15 years
Source: BloombergNEF study, January 2023

**Layout**

Centred composition on a full-bleed photograph. A large headline sits in the upper-middle band, with a thin white horizontal rule beneath it and a subtitle centred below the rule. The source line sits bottom-left with a margin of about 2% of the slide width and height. There is no slide number and no logo.

**Visuals**

One full-bleed greyscale photograph of cracked, weathered dark stone or rock, with deep shadows in the cracks and a grainy texture, showing no people or objects. It is not cropped beyond the slide edges and has no overlay tint. The headline '$1 tn' is set as large white vector glyphs over the photograph. A single white horizontal hairline rule spans about 23% to 75% of the slide width at about 60% of its height. No charts, tables, logos or icons.

**Design**

Background: Greyscale photograph of dark cracked rock, charcoal #2B2B2B to mid grey #5A5A5A, full bleed. Dark, moody, monochrome treatment: a greyscale rock photograph with white type and a white rule. Headline in a bold, high-contrast Didone-style serif (close to Didot or Bodoni Bold) in pure white #FFFFFF, with the glyph height about 36% of the slide height. Subtitle in a bold geometric sans-serif (CentraNo1-Bold, close to Century Gothic Bold) in white #FFFFFF at about 7% of slide height. Source line in a regular geometric sans-serif (CentraNo1-Book) in white #FFFFFF at about 1.8% of slide height. The rule is a 1 px-equivalent hairline in white. No corner radii, shadows or gradients on shapes; the photograph has no gradient overlay.

**Elements and positions** (back to front; x, y, width, height as % of the slide; type, colour and alignment in brackets)

- photo at x 0, y 0, w 100, h 100 [#2B2B2B]: Full-bleed greyscale photograph of cracked dark rock or stone surface, the background behind everything (Dominant colours charcoal #2B2B2B and mid grey #5A5A5A, not cropped, no overlay tint, 1650 by 1093 px source)
- photo at x 12.3, y 1.2, w 56.1, h 87.8 [#5A5A5A]: Photograph fragment of the same cracked rock texture, placed behind the headline (Sits under the headline glyph shapes and is not separately visible; 499 by 440 px image, greyscale rock texture)
- photo at x 39.6, y 1.2, w 51.5, h 87.8 [#5A5A5A]: Second photograph fragment of the same cracked rock texture, placed behind the headline (Sits under the headline glyph shapes and is not separately visible; 458 by 440 px image, greyscale rock texture)
- shape at x 27.2, y 20.4, w 20.8, h 35.8 [#FFFFFF]: White filled glyph shapes forming the dollar sign and the figure 1 of the headline (Vector fill, no stroke, no shadow, no opacity change)
- shape at x 53.8, y 26.7, w 22.4, h 26.1 [#FFFFFF]: White filled glyph shapes forming the letters t and n of the headline (Vector fill, no stroke, no shadow, no opacity change)
- title at x 27.2, y 20.4, w 49, h 32.4 [Didone-style high-contrast serif, bold, mixed case, close to Didot Bold; font size 36% of slide height; #FFFFFF; center aligned]: $1 tn (Headline set as vector glyphs; cap height about 36% of slide height, letter-spacing default; the space between $1 and tn is visible)
- line at x 23.4, y 59.9, w 51.6, h 0.2 [#FFFFFF]: Horizontal white hairline rule separating headline from subtitle (Stroke white, about 1 px wide, no caps, sits centrally below headline, spans roughly 23% to 75% of slide width)
- body at x 40.5, y 66.2, w 19.1, h 7 [CentraNo1-Bold, geometric sans-serif, bold weight, upright, no capitals, normal letter-spacing; font size 7.04% of slide height; #FFFFFF; center aligned]: In 15 years (Single line, centred under the rule)
- footer at x 2.3, y 95.1, w 20.7, h 1.8 [CentraNo1-Book, geometric sans-serif, regular weight, upright, no capitals, normal letter-spacing; font size 1.84% of slide height; #FFFFFF; left aligned]: Source: BloombergNEF study, January 2023 (Bottom-left source line, single line)

**Measured from the file** (exact, read from the PDF rather than estimated; x, y, w, h as % of the slide; font size as % of the slide height)

- fill at x 0.0, y 0.0, w 100.0, h 100.0: #FFFFFF (covers the slide)
- fill at x 27.2, y 20.4, w 20.8, h 35.8: #FFFFFF
- fill at x 53.8, y 26.7, w 22.4, h 26.1: #FFFFFF
- image at x 0.0, y 0.0, w 100.0, h 100.0: 1650 by 1093 pixels (covers the slide)
- image at x 12.3, y 1.2, w 56.1, h 87.8: 499 by 440 pixels
- image at x 39.6, y 1.2, w 51.5, h 87.8: 458 by 440 pixels
- text at x 40.5, y 66.2, w 19.1, h 7.0 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 7.04; #FFFFFF]: In 15 years
- text at x 2.3, y 95.1, w 20.7, h 1.8 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 1.84; #FFFFFF]: Source: BloombergNEF study, January 2023

### Slide 2

**Review notes**

- Worth studying: A stacked bar chart shows the shift in portfolio composition with a clear headline and a labelled source, so the trend reads at a glance.
- Review: Slides 2, 5 and 9 are readable at keynote distance, each carrying one message with a clear hierarchy, and the full-bleed photo on slide 6 gives the room a pause.
- Worth keeping: Keep the big-numeral treatment on slides 1 and 2, the single-message bar chart on slide 5 with direct value labels, and the consistent title, rule and source system.

**Text**

Increasing share of carbon removals / <20% / Share of credits / as removals / 2015-2021 / Portfolios by carbon removal content / 80% - 100% / 19% / 60% - 80% / 33% / 40% - 60% / 21% / 20% - 40% / 22% / 0% - 20% / 5% / 2030 / 52% / of all portfolios will contain / 60%+ of removals by 2030 / 7% / of companies / aiming for / removal only / portfolios / Source: Expert survey, BCG analysis, February 2023

**Layout**

Two-column composition on a white slide: a bold title sits top-left above a thin full-width-of-title rule, with the left column holding the large blue <20% stat, a vertical divider runs down the centre-left, a stacked bar chart occupies the centre, and two stat blocks stack on the right, all aligned to a left margin of about 4% and a right margin of about 4%. The source line sits bottom-left and there is no slide number.

**Visuals**

Stacked bar chart titled 'Portfolios by carbon removal content', single bar labelled 2030 on the x-axis. The y-axis carries the bands 0% - 20%, 20% - 40%, 40% - 60%, 60% - 80%, 80% - 100% (percent of portfolio carbon removal content). Segments from bottom to top: 0% - 20% 5% grey #C0C0C0, 20% - 40% 22% pale yellow #FDEB8C, 40% - 60% 21% dark gold #DAAA00, 60% - 80% 33% light blue #8DC8E8, 80% - 100% 19% blue #3391D8. Segment values are printed inside each segment; no legend. A thin black bracket line spanning the 60% - 80% and 80% - 100% segments (about 52% of the bar height from the top) connects via a horizontal leader to the large 52% statistic. The chart has a black baseline under the bar. Stat '<20%' is printed in blue, not a chart; no photographs, logos or icons.

**Design**

Background: Solid white #FFFFFF. Clean white background with black and blue typography. Title in CentraNo1-Bold sans-serif, black #000000, about 5.0% of slide height, with a thin dark grey rule #333333 under it. Body labels in CentraNo1-Book sans-serif, black #000000, about 3.7% of slide height; axis labels grey #969696 at about 2.2%. Large statistics in Georgia-Bold serif: '<20%' blue #3391D8 at about 14.8%, '52%' black at about 17.8%, '7%' black at about 13.3%. Bar palette: blue #3391D8, light blue #8DC8E8, gold #DAAA00, pale yellow #FDEB8C, grey #C0C0C0. Vertical divider and bracket are solid black lines about 0.2% wide. Source line in CentraNo1-Book grey #808080 at about 1.8%. No shadows, gradients or rounded corners.

**Elements and positions** (back to front; x, y, width, height as % of the slide; type, colour and alignment in brackets)

- shape at x 0, y 0, w 100, h 100 [#FFFFFF]: Full-slide background rectangle, solid white fill (Covers the entire slide, no stroke)
- title at x 4.2, y 6.6, w 47.1, h 5 [CentraNo1-Bold, sans-serif, regular weight, no italics, no capitals; font size 5% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: Increasing share of carbon removals
- line at x 4.2, y 13.6, w 50, h 0.2 [#333333]: Horizontal rule under title (Thin solid line about 0.1% of slide height, spans under title width)
- line at x 33.8, y 25, w 0.2, h 67 [#000000]: Vertical divider line between left and centre columns (Solid black line about 0.2% wide)
- body at x 4.8, y 35.5, w 24.3, h 14.8 [Georgia Bold, serif, bold weight, no italics; font size 14.83% of slide height; #3391D8; center aligned]: <20%
- caption at x 10.7, y 52.8, w 14.7, h 11.7 [CentraNo1-Book, sans-serif, book weight, no italics; font size 3.71% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: Share of credits / as removals / 2015-2021 (Three centred lines, line spacing about 4.4% of slide height)
- line at x 10.5, y 66.8, w 12.5, h 0.4 [#000000]: Short black rule under left stat caption (Solid black horizontal line about 0.4% tall, centred under caption)
- body at x 41.2, y 24, w 24.5, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book, sans-serif, book weight, no italics; font size 2.6% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: Portfolios by carbon removal content (Chart title above bar)
- chart at x 41.2, y 30.1, w 30, h 57: Stacked bar chart, single bar 2030, five segments 5% / 22% / 21% / 33% / 19% (Bar x 51.5 to 59.0 percent of slide width; segments fill from y 70.5 to 82.7 (0% - 20%, #FDEB8C is 20% - 40%), see individual segment elements; y-axis labels at left, year label below)
- shape at x 51.5, y 70.5, w 7.5, h 12.2 [#FDEB8C]: Bar segment 20% - 40% with value 22% (Solid fill, no stroke)
- shape at x 51.5, y 58.9, w 7.5, h 11.6 [#DAAA00]: Bar segment 40% - 60% with value 21% (Solid fill, no stroke)
- shape at x 51.5, y 40.6, w 7.5, h 18.2 [#8DC8E8]: Bar segment 60% - 80% with value 33% (Solid fill, no stroke)
- shape at x 51.5, y 30.1, w 7.5, h 10.5 [#3391D8]: Bar segment 80% - 100% with value 19% (Solid fill, no stroke)
- shape at x 51.5, y 82.3, w 7.5, h 3 [#C0C0C0]: Bar segment 0% - 20% with value 5% (Solid grey fill, no stroke)
- body at x 43.3, y 34.2, w 6.8, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book, sans-serif, book weight, no italics; font size 2.22% of slide height; #969696; right aligned]: 80% - 100% (Y-axis label)
- body at x 54.2, y 34.3, w 2.2, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book, sans-serif, book weight, no italics; font size 2.22% of slide height; #FFFFFF; center aligned]: 19% (Segment value inside blue segment)
- body at x 43.9, y 48.6, w 6.3, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book, sans-serif, book weight, no italics; font size 2.22% of slide height; #969696; right aligned]: 60% - 80% (Y-axis label)
- body at x 54.1, y 48.7, w 2.3, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book, sans-serif, book weight, no italics; font size 2.23% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: 33% (Segment value inside light blue segment)
- body at x 43.8, y 63.5, w 6.3, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book, sans-serif, book weight, no italics; font size 2.22% of slide height; #969696; right aligned]: 40% - 60% (Y-axis label)
- body at x 54.2, y 63.6, w 2.1, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book, sans-serif, book weight, no italics; font size 2.22% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: 21% (Segment value inside gold segment)
- body at x 43.9, y 75.4, w 6.2, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book, sans-serif, book weight, no italics; font size 2.22% of slide height; #969696; right aligned]: 20% - 40% (Y-axis label)
- body at x 54.1, y 75.5, w 2.3, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book, sans-serif, book weight, no italics; font size 2.22% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: 22% (Segment value inside pale yellow segment)
- body at x 44.7, y 82.3, w 5.5, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book, sans-serif, book weight, no italics; font size 2.22% of slide height; #969696; right aligned]: 0% - 20% (Y-axis label)
- body at x 54.4, y 83, w 1.7, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book, sans-serif, book weight, no italics; font size 2.22% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: 5% (Segment value inside grey segment)
- line at x 48.5, y 85.2, w 10, h 0.2 [#000000]: Chart baseline under bar (Solid black horizontal line about 0.2% tall spanning under the bar)
- body at x 53.2, y 87.4, w 4, h 3 [CentraNo1-Bold, sans-serif, bold weight, no italics; font size 2.96% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: 2030 (X-axis year label under bar)
- line at x 61.8, y 30.2, w 0.3, h 26 [#000000]: Vertical bracket line beside 52% statistic (Solid black line about 0.3% wide, spans the 60% - 80% and 80% - 100% segments)
- line at x 61.9, y 36.7, w 9, h 0.2 [#000000]: Horizontal leader from bracket to 52% statistic (Thin solid black horizontal line connecting bracket to the 52% figure)
- body at x 73.4, y 25.9, w 21, h 17.8 [Georgia Bold, serif, bold weight, no italics; font size 17.78% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: 52%
- body at x 71.2, y 46.2, w 26, h 8.2 [CentraNo1-Book, sans-serif, book weight, no italics; font size 3.71% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: of all portfolios will contain / 60%+ of removals by 2030 (Two lines, line spacing about 4.5% of slide height)
- body at x 72.6, y 64.3, w 10.8, h 13.3 [Georgia Bold, serif, bold weight, no italics; font size 13.34% of slide height; #000000; right aligned]: 7%
- body at x 84.1, y 64.2, w 13.2, h 13.6 [CentraNo1-Book, sans-serif, book weight, no italics; font size 3.71% of slide height; #000000; right aligned]: of companies / aiming for / removal only / portfolios (Four right-aligned lines, line spacing about 4.5% of slide height)
- footer at x 2.3, y 95.1, w 23.9, h 1.8 [CentraNo1-Book, sans-serif, book weight, no italics; font size 1.84% of slide height; #808080; left aligned]: Source: Expert survey, BCG analysis, February 2023

**Measured from the file** (exact, read from the PDF rather than estimated; x, y, w, h as % of the slide; font size as % of the slide height)

- fill at x 0.0, y 0.0, w 100.0, h 100.0: #FFFFFF (covers the slide)
- fill at x 51.5, y 70.5, w 7.5, h 12.2: #FDEB8C
- fill at x 51.5, y 58.9, w 7.5, h 11.6: #DAAA00
- fill at x 51.5, y 40.6, w 7.5, h 18.2: #8DC8E8
- fill at x 51.5, y 30.1, w 7.5, h 10.5: #3391D8
- text at x 4.2, y 6.6, w 47.1, h 5.0 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 5.00; #000000]: Increasing share of carbon removals
- text at x 73.4, y 25.9, w 21.0, h 17.8 [Georgia-Bold; font size 17.78; #000000]: 52%
- text at x 4.8, y 35.5, w 24.3, h 14.8 [Georgia-Bold; font size 14.83; #3391D8]: <20%
- text at x 72.6, y 64.3, w 10.8, h 13.3 [Georgia-Bold; font size 13.34; #000000]: 7%
- text at x 41.2, y 24.0, w 24.5, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.60; #000000]: Portfolios by carbon removal content
- text at x 71.2, y 46.2, w 26.0, h 3.7 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 3.71; #000000]: of all portfolios will contain
- text at x 71.2, y 50.7, w 25.4, h 3.7 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 3.72; #000000]: 60%+ of removals by 2030
- text at x 10.7, y 52.8, w 14.7, h 3.7 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 3.71; #000000]: Share of credits
- text at x 12.5, y 57.2, w 11.0, h 3.7 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 3.71; #000000]: as removals
- text at x 43.3, y 34.2, w 6.8, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.22; #969696]: 80% - 100%
- text at x 54.2, y 34.3, w 2.2, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.22; #FFFFFF]: 19%
- text at x 13.4, y 61.6, w 9.4, h 3.7 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 3.71; #000000]: 2015-2021
- text at x 84.1, y 64.2, w 13.2, h 3.7 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 3.71; #000000]: of companies
- text at x 87.3, y 68.7, w 10.0, h 3.7 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 3.71; #000000]: aiming for
- text at x 84.6, y 73.1, w 12.7, h 3.7 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 3.71; #000000]: removal only
- text at x 87.6, y 77.6, w 9.2, h 3.7 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 3.71; #000000]: portfolios
- text at x 43.9, y 48.6, w 6.3, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.22; #969696]: 60% - 80%
- text at x 54.1, y 48.7, w 2.3, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.23; #000000]: 33%
- text at x 43.8, y 63.5, w 6.3, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.22; #969696]: 40% - 60%
- text at x 54.2, y 63.6, w 2.1, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.22; #000000]: 21%
- text at x 53.2, y 87.4, w 4.0, h 3.0 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 2.96; #000000]: 2030
- text at x 43.9, y 75.4, w 6.2, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.22; #969696]: 20% - 40%
- text at x 54.1, y 75.5, w 2.3, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.22; #000000]: 22%
- text at x 44.7, y 82.3, w 5.5, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.22; #969696]: 0% - 20%
- text at x 54.4, y 83.0, w 1.7, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.22; #000000]: 5%
- text at x 2.3, y 95.1, w 23.9, h 1.8 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 1.84; #808080]: Source: Expert survey, BCG analysis, February 2023

### Slide 3

**Text**

Carbon portfolio breakdown to 2050
Indicative breakdown of carbon portfolio over time
100%
80%
60%
40%
20%
0%
1. Avoided emissions and emissions reduction with short lived storage
2. Carbon removal with short lived storage
3. Emissions reduction with long lived storage
4. Carbon removal with long lived storage
2020
2030
2040
2050
Adapted from The Voluntary Carbon Market: Climate Finance at an Inflection Point by World Economic Forum & Bain Company, based on The Oxford Principles for Net Zero Aligned Carbon Offsetting

**Layout**

Single-column, left-aligned composition with a generous white margin of about 4% on the left and about 4% on the right. The title sits top-left at about 6.6% from the top, with a thin dark-grey horizontal rule beneath it running about 52% of the slide width. The chart fills the middle band from about 19% to 92% of the slide height, with the subtitle at top-left of the chart area and the source line in a full-width footer strip at about 95% from the top, left-aligned at 2.3%. No page number or logo is visible.

**Visuals**

One stacked area chart (raster image, 2391 by 1092 px) with the title 'Indicative breakdown of carbon portfolio over time' printed above the plot. Y-axis: percent of carbon portfolio, 0% to 100%, labelled at 0%, 20%, 40%, 60%, 80%, 100%, with gridlines absent and a thin grey vertical axis line. X-axis: years 2020 to 2050, labelled at 2020, 2030, 2040, 2050, with a thin grey horizontal baseline. Four stacked bands, bottom to top: band 4 dark blue (carbon removal with long lived storage) rising from 0% at 2020 to about 35% at 2040 and 100% at about 2050; band 3 light blue (emissions reduction with long lived storage) rising from 0% in 2020 to about 35% in 2040 and 100% at 2050; band 2 teal-green (carbon removal with short lived storage) rising from 0% to about 40% at 2020 and about 80% by 2035 to 100% at 2050; band 1 pale mint (avoided emissions and emissions reduction with short lived storage) occupying the remainder, from about 40% at 2020 up to 100%. Values are not printed; the figures above are estimates marked about. No legend; the four numbered labels act as the legend. Four circular icons sit on the bands: icon 1 two leaves/trees (teal outline) on pale mint at about 2022-2024 band 1; icon 2 same tree icon (teal outline) on teal band near 2030; icon 3 factory with three windows (blue outline) on light blue near 2036; icon 4 storage block with dots and blue stripes (blue outline) on dark blue near 2044. No highlighted points.

**Design**

Background: Solid white #FFFFFF. Clean, flat, corporate infographic. Titles in near-black #000000 bold geometric sans-serif (CentraNo1-Bold, about 5.0% of slide height, capital height about 3.5%). Body and labels in black #000000 CentraNo1-Book about 2.2% of slide height; axis labels in mid grey #808080 about 2.6%. Footer source line in grey #808080 CentraNo1-Book about 1.8%, with the two titled references underlined. Accents: pale mint #CFE3DF, sage teal #7FB9AD, light blue #8EC6EA, mid blue #3A90D0. Thin dark grey rule #404040 about 1 px. Icon circles are white with a 2 px outline in teal #5BA89A or blue #3A8FD0 and a soft drop shadow. No corner radii on the chart; no gradients; no texture.

**Elements and positions** (back to front; x, y, width, height as % of the slide; type, colour and alignment in brackets)

- shape at x 0, y 0, w 100, h 100 [#FFFFFF]: Full-slide white background rectangle (Covers the whole slide, no border, no shadow.)
- shape at x 47.7, y 58, w 4.8, h 8.4 [#FFFFFF]: White rectangle behind icon 3 (Plain white fill, no outline; sits behind the factory icon circle and is visually indistinguishable from the background.)
- chart at x 3.2, y 19.2, w 89.7, h 72.8 [#CFE3DF]: Stacked area chart image: indicative breakdown of carbon portfolio over time, 0% to 100%, 2020 to 2050, four bands with numbered labels and four circular icons (Raster image 2391 by 1092 px placed unclipped, not full-bleed, no border, no overlay. Band fills: #CFE3DF, #7FB9AD, #8EC6EA, #3A90D0. Thin grey axis lines #808080 at left (x about 10.3%, from 20% to 92%) and along the bottom (y about 83.5%, to about 92% x). Plot area occupies x 10.3% to 89.8%, y 25.1% to 83.6%.)
- icon at x 14.6, y 29, w 6.2, h 11 [#FFFFFF]: Icon 1: two leaf-tree symbols in a white circle, teal outline (White circle about 6.2% wide with 2 px #5BA89A outline and soft drop shadow; contains a small leaf-tree and a cloud-tree in teal #5BA89A and black; sits on the pale mint band.)
- text at x 22.2, y 29.6, w 12.9, h 9.7 [CentraNo1 Bold; font size 2.2% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: 1. Avoided emissions / and emissions / reduction with short / lived storage (Numeral 1 followed by a period; line spacing about 1.2; hanging indent so continuation lines align after the numeral.)
- icon at x 32.5, y 45.5, w 6, h 10.7 [#FFFFFF]: Icon 2: two leaf-tree symbols in a white circle, teal outline (White circle with 2 px #5BA89A outline and soft drop shadow; sits on the teal band.)
- text at x 38.9, y 43.4, w 11.5, h 7.3 [CentraNo1 Bold; font size 2.2% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: 2. Carbon removal / with short lived / storage (Numeral 2 followed by a period; line spacing about 1.2; hanging indent.)
- icon at x 47, y 56.5, w 6.1, h 11 [#FFFFFF]: Icon 3: factory with three windows in a white circle, blue outline (White circle with 2 px #3A8FD0 outline and soft drop shadow; black-outline factory with sawtooth roof and a blue-outlined front with three small windows; sits on the light blue band.)
- text at x 53, y 53.5, w 9.5, h 9.8 [CentraNo1 Bold; font size 2.2% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: 3. Emissions / reduction / with long / lived storage (Numeral 3 followed by a period; line spacing about 1.2; hanging indent.)
- icon at x 62.2, y 67.6, w 6.1, h 11 [#FFFFFF]: Icon 4: storage block with dots and stripes in a white circle, blue outline (White circle with 2 px #3A8FD0 outline and soft drop shadow; black-outline block with blue vertical stripes at left and round dots inside, two small feet; sits on the dark blue band.)
- text at x 69.3, y 67.7, w 11.5, h 7.4 [CentraNo1 Bold; font size 2.2% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: 4. Carbon removal / with long lived / storage (Numeral 4 followed by a period; line spacing about 1.2; hanging indent.)
- line at x 10.3, y 20.4, w 0.1, h 72 [#808080]: Vertical y-axis line (Thin grey line about 1 px, from the top of the chart area down to the baseline.)
- line at x 10.3, y 83.5, w 82, h 0.1 [#808080]: Horizontal x-axis baseline (Thin grey line about 1 px extending slightly past the 2050 point.)
- text at x 4.2, y 24.3, w 3.8, h 2.4 [CentraNo1 Book; font size 2.6% of slide height; #808080; right aligned]: 100% (Y-axis tick label.)
- text at x 4.5, y 35.7, w 3.2, h 2.5 [CentraNo1 Book; font size 2.6% of slide height; #808080; right aligned]: 80% (Y-axis tick label.)
- text at x 4.5, y 47.5, w 3.2, h 2.5 [CentraNo1 Book; font size 2.6% of slide height; #808080; right aligned]: 60% (Y-axis tick label.)
- text at x 4.5, y 58.9, w 3.2, h 2.5 [CentraNo1 Book; font size 2.6% of slide height; #808080; right aligned]: 40% (Y-axis tick label.)
- text at x 4.5, y 70.2, w 3.2, h 2.5 [CentraNo1 Book; font size 2.6% of slide height; #808080; right aligned]: 20% (Y-axis tick label.)
- text at x 5, y 81.3, w 2.3, h 2.4 [CentraNo1 Book; font size 2.6% of slide height; #808080; right aligned]: 0% (Y-axis tick label.)
- text at x 10.2, y 88.6, w 3.5, h 2.5 [CentraNo1 Book; font size 2.6% of slide height; #808080; left aligned]: 2020 (X-axis tick label.)
- text at x 35, y 88.6, w 3.5, h 2.5 [CentraNo1 Book; font size 2.6% of slide height; #808080; left aligned]: 2030 (X-axis tick label.)
- text at x 60.5, y 88.6, w 3.8, h 2.5 [CentraNo1 Book; font size 2.6% of slide height; #808080; left aligned]: 2040 (X-axis tick label.)
- text at x 86.1, y 88.6, w 3.7, h 2.5 [CentraNo1 Book; font size 2.6% of slide height; #808080; left aligned]: 2050 (X-axis tick label.)
- line at x 4.2, y 13.8, w 51.8, h 0.1 [#404040]: Thin dark grey rule under the title (Horizontal line about 1 px, left edge aligned with the title.)
- text at x 4.2, y 6.6, w 48.6, h 5 [CentraNo1 Bold; font size 5% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: Carbon portfolio breakdown to 2050 (Sentence case, no letter-spacing change, single line.)
- text at x 11.8, y 20.6, w 29, h 2.2 [CentraNo1 Book; font size 2.23% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: Indicative breakdown of carbon portfolio over time (Sentence case, regular weight, single line; sits at the top of the chart area.)
- text at x 2.3, y 95.1, w 93.8, h 1.8 [CentraNo1 Book; font size 1.84% of slide height; #808080; left aligned]: Adapted from The Voluntary Carbon Market: Climate Finance at an Inflection Point by World Economic Forum & Bain Company, based on The Oxford Principles for Net Zero Aligned Carbon Offsetting (Single line. The titles 'The Voluntary Carbon Market: Climate Finance at an Inflection Point' and 'The Oxford Principles for Net Zero Aligned Carbon Offsetting' are hyperlinked and underlined in grey #808080; the rest of the text is not underlined.)

**Measured from the file** (exact, read from the PDF rather than estimated; x, y, w, h as % of the slide; font size as % of the slide height)

- fill at x 0.0, y 0.0, w 100.0, h 100.0: #FFFFFF (covers the slide)
- fill at x 47.7, y 58.0, w 4.8, h 8.4: #FFFFFF
- image at x 3.2, y 19.2, w 89.7, h 72.8: 2391 by 1092 pixels
- text at x 4.2, y 6.6, w 48.6, h 5.0 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 5.00; #000000]: Carbon portfolio breakdown to 2050
- text at x 11.8, y 20.6, w 29.0, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.23; #000000]: Indicative breakdown of carbon portfolio over time
- text at x 2.3, y 95.1, w 93.8, h 1.8 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 1.84; #808080]: Adapted from The Voluntary Carbon Market: Climate Finance at an Inflection Point by World Economic Forum & Bain Company, based on The Oxford Principles for Net Zero Aligned Carbon Offsetting

### Slide 4

**Review notes**

- Worth studying: Three short, parallel attributes beneath a single headline state the core benefit claim with minimal text.

**Text**

Direct air capture has clear benefits
100%
Fully
additional
Fully
measurable
No
arable land

**Layout**

Single-row composition of a title at top left over a thin rule, with three equal-width circular items spaced across the slide on one horizontal band, each with a caption centred beneath it. The title sits at about 6.6% from the top and the left margin is about 4.2%; the content band is vertically centred in the lower two-thirds. No footer, slide number or logo is present.

**Visuals**

Three circular items in a row. (1) A white filled circle, centre about x 14.5%, y 46%, diameter about 20.7% of slide width, containing the text '100%' in a bold high-contrast serif (Georgia Bold, black #000000), centred. (2) A circular photograph, centre about x 49.5%, y 46%, diameter about 20.7% of width, showing a close-up of a yellow retractable tape measure at left (with a black belt clip and three silver rivets, markings '3 cm' and '2') beside a grey-steel metal ruler labelled 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 with 'METER' printed under 4, and a second grey ruler at right labelled 1, 2, 3, 4 and 32 at its edge; background is plain white, lit evenly from above, neutral grey and yellow dominant colours, tightly framed and cropped to the circle. (3) A circular photograph, centre about x 84.5%, y 46%, diameter about 20.7% of width, showing a red tractor with cab and a trailing red-and-grey cultivator on bare brown tilled soil, under a blue sky with scattered white cumulus clouds; low camera angle with the horizon near the lower-middle of the circle; daylight; dominant colours blue, brown and red; full image cropped to the circle, no overlay or tint.

**Design**

Background: Solid light blue #8DC8E8 covering the whole slide.

**Elements and positions** (back to front; x, y, width, height as % of the slide; type, colour and alignment in brackets)

- title at x 4.2, y 6.6, w 46.2, h 5 [CentraNo1 Bold (closest generic: geometric sans-serif, bold); font size 5% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: Direct air capture has clear benefits (Single line; a thin dark navy rule (#1F3A5F, about 0.1% of height stroke) runs beneath it from x 4.2% to x 52.1% at y about 13.8%.)
- shape at x 4.2, y 13.7, w 47.9, h 0.2 [#1F3A5F]: Thin horizontal rule under title (Straight line, stroke about 1 px, dark navy, spanning beneath the title.)
- shape at x 4.2, y 28.7, w 20.7, h 36.7 [#FFFFFF]: White filled circle behind '100%' (Perfect circle, no outline, no shadow, fully opaque.)
- body at x 5.7, y 41.4, w 17.3, h 11.1 [Georgia Bold (serif, bold); font size 11.12% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: 100% (Single line, centred within the white circle.)
- photo at x 39.2, y 28.7, w 20.7, h 36.7 [#FFFFFF]: Close-up of yellow tape measure and two steel rulers on white background, circular crop (Circular crop (ellipse mask), fully opaque, no overlay, no border, source 550 by 550 pixels.)
- photo at x 74.2, y 29, w 20.7, h 36.4 [#8DC8E8]: Red tractor cultivating brown soil under blue sky with clouds, circular crop (Circular crop (ellipse mask), fully opaque, no overlay, no border, source 338 by 335 pixels.)
- body at x 7.8, y 68.5, w 17.8, h 11 [CentraNo1 Bold (closest generic: geometric sans-serif, bold); font size 5% of slide height; #FFFFFF; center aligned]: Fully / additional (Two lines, line spacing about 1.2 times font size; 'Fully' at x 11.4% y 68.5%, 'additional' at x 7.8% y 74.5%.)
- body at x 41.8, y 68.5, w 15.4, h 11 [CentraNo1 Bold (closest generic: geometric sans-serif, bold); font size 5% of slide height; #FFFFFF; center aligned]: Fully / measurable (Two lines, line spacing about 1.2 times font size; 'Fully' at x 46.4% y 68.5%, 'measurable' at x 41.8% y 74.5%.)
- body at x 77.1, y 68.5, w 14.7, h 11 [CentraNo1 Bold (closest generic: geometric sans-serif, bold); font size 5% of slide height; #FFFFFF; center aligned]: No / arable land (Two lines, line spacing about 1.2 times font size; 'No' at x 82.6% y 68.5%, 'arable land' at x 77.1% y 74.5%.)

**Measured from the file** (exact, read from the PDF rather than estimated; x, y, w, h as % of the slide; font size as % of the slide height)

- fill at x 0.0, y 0.0, w 100.0, h 100.0: #8DC8E8 (covers the slide)
- fill at x 4.2, y 28.7, w 20.7, h 36.7: #FFFFFF
- image at x 39.2, y 28.7, w 20.7, h 36.7: 550 by 550 pixels
- image at x 74.2, y 29.0, w 20.7, h 36.4: 338 by 335 pixels
- text at x 4.2, y 6.6, w 46.2, h 5.0 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 5.00; #000000]: Direct air capture has clear benefits
- text at x 5.7, y 41.4, w 17.3, h 11.1 [Georgia-Bold; font size 11.12; #000000]: 100%
- text at x 11.4, y 68.5, w 6.9, h 5.0 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 5.00; #FFFFFF]: Fully
- text at x 46.4, y 68.5, w 6.9, h 5.0 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 5.00; #FFFFFF]: Fully
- text at x 82.6, y 68.5, w 4.5, h 5.0 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 5.00; #FFFFFF]: No
- text at x 7.8, y 74.5, w 13.4, h 5.0 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 5.00; #FFFFFF]: additional
- text at x 41.8, y 74.5, w 15.4, h 5.0 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 5.00; #FFFFFF]: measurable
- text at x 77.1, y 74.5, w 14.7, h 5.0 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 5.00; #FFFFFF]: arable land

### Slide 5

**Review notes**

- Worth studying: A bar chart of mitigation potential across removal methods makes the comparison visible, with the ranges and source printed directly on the slide.
- Review: Slides 2, 5 and 9 are readable at keynote distance, each carrying one message with a clear hierarchy, and the full-bleed photo on slide 6 gives the room a pause.
- Worth keeping: Keep the big-numeral treatment on slides 1 and 2, the single-message bar chart on slide 5 with direct value labels, and the consistent title, rule and source system.

**Text**

Large scale carbon removal is needed / Mitigation potential for selected CDR methods, in Gt CO2e per year / Afforestation & Reforestation / 0.5-10 / Biochar / 0.3-6.6 / Enhanced weathering / 2-4 / BECCS / 0.5-11 / DAC / 5-40 / 0 / 10 / 20 / 30 / 40 / Source: IPCC – only selected CDR methods displayed

**Layout**

Single left-aligned title block at top-left with a full-width-of-title dark rule beneath it, then a bold-plus-regular chart caption with a thin rule across the slide body. Below, a horizontal range-bar chart fills the slide: category labels right-aligned in a column ending near 23% of slide width, small icons in a column at about 25% to 29%, and bars starting at 0 on a shared axis from about 31% to 88% of width. The x-axis ticks and labels sit along the bottom of the chart at about 82% to 88% of height. The source line sits bottom-left at about 95% of height. No slide number is shown and there is no logo.

**Visuals**

Horizontal floating range-bar chart. Title: none inside chart; caption above it reads 'Mitigation potential for selected CDR methods, in Gt CO2e per year'. X-axis: linear, labelled 0, 10, 20, 30, 40 with grey tick marks, axis line runs from 0 to about 44 Gt CO2e per year, no axis title beyond the caption, unit Gt CO2e per year. Y-axis: categorical, no axis line. Series (one bar per method, printed values): Afforestation & Reforestation 0.5-10, bar #67AEA2 spanning 0.5 to 10; Biochar 0.3-6.6, bar #FDEB8C spanning 0.3 to 6.6; Enhanced weathering 2-4, bar light blue #91C8E8 spanning 2 to 4 (colour estimated); BECCS 0.5-11, bar #C2DFDA spanning 0.5 to 11; DAC 5-40, bar #419FE7 spanning 5 to 40. Bars are solid rectangles with no outline, each value label printed to the right of its bar in black. No legend. No highlighted points beyond the colour of each bar. Icons: Afforestation and Reforestation icon (blue-outlined leaf with black sprout beside blue-outlined round tree canopy with black trunk); Biochar icon (blue-outlined leaves above a cluster of grey outlined round granules); Enhanced weathering icon (row of small black-outlined pebbles and blue dots scattered on a black ground line, with a blue dot at right end); BECCS icon (black-outlined leaf with sprout beside a blue-outlined factory with stacks and a black stacked-box symbol at its base); DAC icon (black-outlined rectangular block with blue vertical stripes on its left face and black-outlined dots filling its top face, standing on two small square legs). All icons are line icons, black and blue, about 3% to 4% of slide width.

**Design**

Background: Solid white #FFFFFF. Clean white background, minimal corporate style. Title in bold black (#000000) geometric humanist sans-serif, CentraNo1-Bold style, about 5.0% of slide height. Caption bold part and regular part in black #000000, sans-serif (CentraNo1 Bold and Book), about 2.6% of slide height. Category and value labels in black #000000 CentraNo1 Book, about 2.6%. Axis tick labels in grey #929292, about 2.6%. Source line in grey #808080, about 1.84%. Bar colours: #67AEA2 teal-green, #FDEB8C pale yellow, #91C8E8 light blue, #C2DFDA pale mint, #419FE7 bright blue. Rules are thin dark grey lines (#333333), about 0.1% of height thick, square ends, no shadow. Axis line and ticks are mid grey (#929292), thin, no corner radius, no shadow, no gradients.

**Elements and positions** (back to front; x, y, width, height as % of the slide; type, colour and alignment in brackets)

- shape at x 0, y 0, w 100, h 100 [#FFFFFF]: Full-slide background fill, white rectangle (covers entire slide, no outline, no shadow)
- line at x 4.2, y 13.8, w 52.9, h 0.2 [#333333]: Rule under title (horizontal straight line, stroke about 0.1% of slide height, square ends, no shadow)
- title at x 4.2, y 6.6, w 48.7, h 5 [CentraNo1-Bold, bold, sans-serif, normal case, no letter-spacing; font size 5% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: Large scale carbon removal is needed
- body at x 3.9, y 23.7, w 32.2, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Bold, bold, sans-serif, normal case; font size 2.6% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: Mitigation potential for selected CDR methods,
- body at x 36.1, y 23.7, w 12.8, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book, regular, sans-serif, normal case; font size 2.6% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: in Gt CO2e per year (the 2 is a subscript printed at x 41.7, y 25.1, w 0.5, h 1.7, size 1.73)
- line at x 3.6, y 27.3, w 92.5, h 0.1 [#333333]: Rule under chart caption spanning the slide body (horizontal straight line, stroke about 0.1% of slide height, no shadow)
- icon at x 25, y 33.8, w 3.75, h 5.3 [#3A9BDC]: Afforestation and reforestation icon: blue-outlined leaf with black sprout beside blue-outlined round tree canopy with black trunk (line icon, black and blue outlines, no fill, positioned left of its bar)
- shape at x 31.6, y 34, w 13.6, h 5.3 [#67AEA2]: Bar for Afforestation & Reforestation, spanning 0.5 to 10 (solid rectangle, no outline, no corner radius, no shadow)
- body at x 3.8, y 35.4, w 19.3, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book, regular, sans-serif, normal case; font size 2.6% of slide height; #000000; right aligned]: Afforestation & Reforestation
- body at x 46.1, y 35.4, w 4.2, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book, regular, sans-serif, normal case; font size 2.6% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: 0.5-10
- icon at x 25.6, y 45.3, w 2.5, h 2.9 [#8A8A8A]: Biochar icon: blue-outlined leaves above a cluster of grey outlined round granules (raster image 69 by 45 pixels, placed at this box, no border, no crop)
- shape at x 31.4, y 43.4, w 9, h 5.2 [#FDEB8C]: Bar for Biochar, spanning 0.3 to 6.6 (solid rectangle, no outline, no corner radius, no shadow)
- body at x 18.2, y 44.8, w 5, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book, regular, sans-serif, normal case; font size 2.6% of slide height; #000000; right aligned]: Biochar
- body at x 41.5, y 44.7, w 4.8, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book, regular, sans-serif, normal case; font size 2.6% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: 0.3-6.6
- icon at x 24.8, y 54.2, w 3.9, h 3.1 [#000000]: Enhanced weathering icon: row of small black-outlined pebbles and blue dots on a black ground line (line icon, black and blue, no fill)
- shape at x 34.1, y 52.7, w 2.9, h 5.2 [#91C8E8]: Bar for Enhanced weathering, spanning 2 to 4 (solid rectangle, no outline, no corner radius, no shadow; colour estimated)
- body at x 8.9, y 54.1, w 14.3, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book, regular, sans-serif, normal case; font size 2.6% of slide height; #000000; right aligned]: Enhanced weathering
- body at x 38, y 54.1, w 2.2, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book, regular, sans-serif, normal case; font size 2.6% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: 2-4
- icon at x 24.8, y 61.8, w 4.25, h 5.3 [#000000]: BECCS icon: black-outlined leaf with sprout beside blue-outlined factory with stacks and black stacked-box symbol at its base (line icon, black and blue, no fill)
- shape at x 31.6, y 62.1, w 15.1, h 5.2 [#C2DFDA]: Bar for BECCS, spanning 0.5 to 11 (solid rectangle, no outline, no corner radius, no shadow)
- body at x 18.7, y 63.5, w 4.4, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book, regular, sans-serif, normal case; font size 2.6% of slide height; #000000; right aligned]: BECCS
- body at x 47.5, y 63.5, w 3.7, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book, regular, sans-serif, normal case; font size 2.6% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: 0.5-11
- icon at x 25.7, y 71.6, w 3.45, h 4.9 [#000000]: DAC icon: black-outlined block with blue vertical stripes on its left face and black dots on its top face, on two small square legs (line icon, black and blue, no fill)
- shape at x 38.1, y 71.5, w 50.2, h 5.2 [#419FE7]: Bar for DAC, spanning 5 to 40 (solid rectangle, no outline, no corner radius, no shadow)
- body at x 20.2, y 72.9, w 3, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book, regular, sans-serif, normal case; font size 2.6% of slide height; #000000; right aligned]: DAC
- body at x 89.2, y 72.9, w 3.2, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book, regular, sans-serif, normal case; font size 2.6% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: 5-40
- line at x 30.9, y 82.7, w 63.7, h 0.2 [#929292]: X-axis line for the chart, from 0 to about 44 (horizontal straight line, thin, no shadow)
- line at x 30.9, y 81.6, w 0.1, h 2 [#929292]: Axis tick mark at 0 (short vertical tick, thin)
- line at x 45.2, y 81.6, w 0.1, h 2 [#929292]: Axis tick mark at 10 (short vertical tick, thin)
- line at x 59.5, y 81.6, w 0.1, h 2 [#929292]: Axis tick mark at 20 (short vertical tick, thin)
- line at x 73.9, y 81.6, w 0.1, h 2 [#929292]: Axis tick mark at 30 (short vertical tick, thin)
- line at x 88.3, y 81.6, w 0.1, h 2 [#929292]: Axis tick mark at 40 (short vertical tick, thin)
- body at x 30.4, y 85.2, w 1, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book, regular, sans-serif, normal case; font size 2.6% of slide height; #929292; center aligned]: 0
- body at x 44.5, y 85.2, w 1.5, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book, regular, sans-serif, normal case; font size 2.6% of slide height; #929292; center aligned]: 10
- body at x 58.8, y 85.2, w 1.7, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book, regular, sans-serif, normal case; font size 2.6% of slide height; #929292; center aligned]: 20
- body at x 73.1, y 85.2, w 1.7, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book, regular, sans-serif, normal case; font size 2.6% of slide height; #929292; center aligned]: 30
- body at x 87.4, y 85.2, w 1.8, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book, regular, sans-serif, normal case; font size 2.6% of slide height; #929292; center aligned]: 40
- footer at x 2.3, y 94.9, w 24.9, h 1.8 [CentraNo1-Book, regular, sans-serif, normal case; font size 1.84% of slide height; #808080; left aligned]: Source: IPCC – only selected CDR methods displayed

**Measured from the file** (exact, read from the PDF rather than estimated; x, y, w, h as % of the slide; font size as % of the slide height)

- fill at x 0.0, y 0.0, w 100.0, h 100.0: #FFFFFF (covers the slide)
- fill at x 31.6, y 34.0, w 13.6, h 5.3: #67AEA2
- fill at x 31.4, y 43.4, w 9.0, h 5.2: #FDEB8C
- fill at x 31.6, y 62.1, w 15.1, h 5.2: #C2DFDA
- fill at x 38.1, y 71.5, w 50.2, h 5.2: #419FE7
- image at x 25.6, y 45.3, w 2.5, h 2.9: 69 by 45 pixels
- text at x 4.2, y 6.6, w 48.7, h 5.0 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 5.00; #000000]: Large scale carbon removal is needed
- text at x 3.9, y 23.7, w 32.2, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 2.60; #000000]: Mitigation potential for selected CDR methods,
- text at x 36.1, y 23.7, w 12.8, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.60; #000000]: in Gt CO e per year
- text at x 3.8, y 35.4, w 19.3, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.60; #000000]: Afforestation & Reforestation
- text at x 46.1, y 35.4, w 4.2, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.60; #000000]: 0.5-10
- text at x 41.7, y 25.1, w 0.5, h 1.7 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 1.73; #000000]: 2
- text at x 18.2, y 44.8, w 5.0, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.60; #000000]: Biochar
- text at x 41.5, y 44.7, w 4.8, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.60; #000000]: 0.3-6.6
- text at x 8.9, y 54.1, w 14.3, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.60; #000000]: Enhanced weathering
- text at x 38.0, y 54.1, w 2.2, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.60; #000000]: 2-4
- text at x 18.7, y 63.5, w 4.4, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.60; #000000]: BECCS
- text at x 47.5, y 63.5, w 3.7, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.60; #000000]: 0.5-11
- text at x 20.2, y 72.9, w 3.0, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.60; #000000]: DAC
- text at x 89.2, y 72.9, w 3.2, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.60; #000000]: 5-40
- text at x 30.4, y 85.2, w 1.0, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.60; #929292]: 0
- text at x 44.5, y 85.2, w 1.5, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.60; #929292]: 10
- text at x 58.8, y 85.2, w 1.7, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.60; #929292]: 20
- text at x 73.1, y 85.2, w 1.7, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.60; #929292]: 30
- text at x 87.4, y 85.2, w 1.8, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.60; #929292]: 40
- text at x 2.3, y 94.9, w 24.9, h 1.8 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 1.84; #808080]: Source: IPCC – only selected CDR methods displayed

### Slide 6

**Review notes**

- Review: Slides 2, 5 and 9 are readable at keynote distance, each carrying one message with a clear hierarchy, and the full-bleed photo on slide 6 gives the room a pause.

**Text**

No words are printed on the slide. The only lettering is 'CAPITAL' painted on a container at the far right edge of the photograph.

**Layout**

A single full-bleed photograph fills the whole slide edge to edge with no title, text block, footer, logo or slide number. The main subject sits in the centre-to-lower half, with the sky occupying the upper half.

**Visuals**

Photograph, full-bleed, landscape. Subject: an outdoor industrial installation on a grassy, gravelly plateau. Three large black-and-grey louvred modules stand on concrete pads: a left module angled with its face toward the viewer, a larger centre-right module, and a smaller module at the far right partly cut off by the frame edge. Between the left and centre modules stands an open steel frame cage (grey-green painted I-beams and diagonal bracing) holding a dense cluster of grey insulated pipes, valves and small electrical boxes. A grey corrugated-metal shed with a roller door is at the far left. A white container and a dark green container with the word 'CAPITAL' are at the far right, with a low tan hillside behind them. Pipes run along the ground at the right. Composition: low camera angle, centred, subject filling the middle band, horizon low in frame. Lighting: soft daylight with diffuse sun, no hard shadows. Dominant colours: blue sky #4A90C8 fading to pale #DDE8F0 near the horizon, white cumulus clouds, charcoal #2E2E2E and dark slate #3A3F44 louvres, grey-green steel #6B7566, concrete #9A9A96, grass and gravel foreground #4E5A36 with dark soil #2B2A26. Not cropped apart from the right-hand module touching the edge; no overlay or tint.

**Design**

Background: Photograph of blue sky with white clouds above a grassy, gravelly ground with the industrial installation in the middle distance. No typography on the slide apart from the 'CAPITAL' lettering on the container, which is white capitals on dark green. No border, frame or shape styling. Photographic look with natural colour, moderate contrast and slight softness at the edges. No gradients, shadows added or corner radii.

**Elements and positions** (back to front; x, y, width, height as % of the slide; type, colour and alignment in brackets)

- photo at x 0, y 0, w 100, h 100: Full-bleed photograph of an outdoor louvred-module industrial installation with a central steel pipe frame, a metal shed at left, and a container marked CAPITAL at right, under a blue sky with clouds (Full-bleed, uncropped rectangle filling the slide edge to edge; no overlay, tint, border or rounded corners; the right-hand module is cut off by the right edge.)

### Slide 7

**Review notes**

- Review: Weaknesses remain: slide 1 shows '$1 tn' with no object, so the opener is unexplained, slide 7's waterfall uses tiny annotation text and slide 8 is a sparse diagram, and the ending on slide 10 is a modest chart with no closing statement.
- Suggested repair: Say what the $1 tn is on slide 1, enlarge the annotations on slide 7, and make slide 10 land the 40 percent versus 20 percent point, which is currently confusing against the donut labels.
- What would change the score: I would give slide 8 more substance or merge it with slide 7, and close with a statement slide that states the takeaway for the audience.

**Text**

From capture to removal / CDR production efficiency / Availability / Performance / Recovery / Grey emissions / Planned and / unplanned / downtime / 10% / Wind, weather, and / sorbent degradation / losses / 0% (average) / CO2 extraction and / purification losses / 5% / Accounting for grey / emissions of full / supply chain / 15% / Complete process is 3rd party verified / Nameplate CO2 / capture capacity / Available CO2 / capture capacity / CO2 / captured / CO2 / stored / CDR / produced / CO2 quantities / Corrections & losses / Net CDR

**Layout**

Title sits top-left at about 4 percent from the left edge, left-aligned at about 6.6 percent from the top, with a thin dark hairline rule beneath it spanning about 39 percent of the width. The main area is a horizontal waterfall of five bars across the middle of the slide, with a bracket arrow above, four step labels and callout boxes between the bars, a grey hatched band crossing the bars, a legend row near the bottom, and a circular certificate icon at the right; no page number or footer is visible.

**Visuals**

Waterfall chart with five vertical bars and four correction steps, no axes or gridlines. Bar 1 Nameplate CO2 capture capacity is light blue, tall, starting at the baseline. Step labelled Availability is a yellow block dropping from the top of bar 1 with callout Planned and unplanned downtime 10%. Bar 2 Available CO2 capture capacity is light blue and lower. Step labelled Performance has a callout Wind, weather, and sorbent degradation losses 0% (average) and no visible yellow block. Bar 3 CO2 captured is light blue, same height as bar 2. Step labelled Recovery is a small yellow block with callout CO2 extraction and purification losses 5%. Bar 4 CO2 stored is light blue and lower. Step labelled Grey emissions is a yellow block with callout Accounting for grey emissions of full supply chain 15%. Bar 5 CDR produced is a darker blue bar at the lowest level. A thin black elbow arrow labelled CDR production efficiency runs from above bar 1 horizontally to the right and drops down with an arrowhead onto the top of bar 5. A grey hatched horizontal band runs behind the bars with the bold label Complete process is 3rd party verified centred on it. Legend at bottom left: light blue square labelled CO2 quantities, yellow square labelled Corrections & losses, dark blue square labelled Net CDR. Icon at right: a circular outline in blue containing a black line-drawn document with three text lines, a rosette seal with a blue check mark, all within a blue ring; framing is centred and unboxed apart from the ring.

**Design**

Background: Solid white #FFFFFF. Plain white background with no gradient. Title and all labels are black #000000 in a geometric sans-serif bold (CentraNo1-Bold, close to Century Gothic style), with body and callout text in CentraNo1-Book regular black. Title height is about 5 percent of slide height; bar labels and callout text about 1.8 to 2.2 percent. Light blue bars #8EC7E9, yellow correction blocks #FFEB8A, dark blue CDR bar and icon ring #419FE8. Callout boxes are white with thin black 1 px stroke and square corners, with a small wedge pointer on the top edge. Connector and hairline are thin dark grey #333333 about 1 px. Hatched band is light grey #E6E6E6 with a fine dotted pattern. No shadows.

**Elements and positions** (back to front; x, y, width, height as % of the slide; type, colour and alignment in brackets)

- shape at x 4.9, y 58.5, w 82.5, h 5.5 [#E6E6E6]: Hatched grey horizontal band behind bars (Fine dotted hatch pattern in grey, sits behind bars and under the bold label, no border)
- shape at x 6.7, y 29.9, w 6, h 44.1 [#8EC7E9]: Bar 1 Nameplate CO2 capture capacity (Rectangle, square corners, no outline)
- shape at x 24.7, y 33.3, w 6, h 40.7 [#8EC7E9]: Bar 2 Available CO2 capture capacity (Rectangle, square corners, no outline)
- shape at x 42.8, y 33.3, w 6, h 40.7 [#8EC7E9]: Bar 3 CO2 captured (Rectangle, square corners, no outline)
- shape at x 60.8, y 35.4, w 6, h 38.6 [#8EC7E9]: Bar 4 CO2 stored (Rectangle, square corners, no outline)
- shape at x 78.8, y 40.7, w 6, h 33.2 [#419FE8]: Bar 5 CDR produced (Rectangle, square corners, no outline, darker blue than other bars)
- shape at x 15.7, y 29.9, w 6, h 3.3 [#FFEB8A]: Yellow step block Availability (Rectangle floating from top of bar 1 to bar 2 level, square corners)
- shape at x 51.8, y 33.4, w 6, h 2 [#FFEB8A]: Yellow step block Recovery (Rectangle, square corners)
- shape at x 69.8, y 35.4, w 6, h 5.6 [#FFEB8A]: Yellow step block Grey emissions (Rectangle, square corners)
- line at x 14, y 29.9, w 67, h 14.7 [#C8C8C8]: Thin grey step connectors between bars and blocks (Horizontal hairlines about 1 px at the top of each step)
- line at x 10, y 23.4, w 71.4, h 15.7 [#000000]: CDR production efficiency bracket: horizontal line then vertical arrow down to bar 5 (Black line about 1 px, elbow shape: runs horizontally from x 10 to x 81.3 at y 23.4, then drops vertically to y 39.1 with a small filled arrowhead pointing down onto bar 5)
- shape at x 13.9, y 44.6, w 10.3, h 11.7 [#FFFFFF]: Callout box Planned and unplanned downtime (White box with thin black 1 px stroke, square corners, small wedge pointer on top edge)
- shape at x 31.6, y 44.7, w 10.3, h 11.7 [#FFFFFF]: Callout box Wind weather sorbent degradation (White box with thin black 1 px stroke, square corners, small wedge pointer on top edge)
- shape at x 50, y 45.1, w 10.3, h 9.1 [#FFFFFF]: Callout box CO2 extraction and purification losses (White box with thin black 1 px stroke, square corners, small wedge pointer on top edge)
- shape at x 68.1, y 44.8, w 10.3, h 11.7 [#FFFFFF]: Callout box Accounting for grey emissions (White box with thin black 1 px stroke, square corners, small wedge pointer on top edge)
- text at x 32.9, y 60.3, w 29.1, h 3 [CentraNo1-Bold, sans-serif, regular case; font size 2.96% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: Complete process is 3rd party verified (Superscript rd on 3rd, sits over hatched band and overlaps bars 3 and 4)
- text at x 16.1, y 47.1, w 6.1, h 8.5 [CentraNo1-Book, sans-serif, regular weight, regular case; font size 1.84% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: Planned and / unplanned / downtime / 10% (Last line 10% in CentraNo1-Bold, line spacing about 1.2)
- text at x 31.9, y 47.2, w 9.9, h 8.5 [CentraNo1-Book, sans-serif, regular weight, regular case; font size 1.84% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: Wind, weather, and / sorbent degradation / losses / 0% (average) (0% in CentraNo1-Bold, (average) in regular, line spacing about 1.2)
- text at x 50.6, y 47.3, w 9.2, h 6.2 [CentraNo1-Book, sans-serif, regular weight, regular case; font size 1.85% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: CO2 extraction and / purification losses / 5% (CO2 with subscript 2, 5% in CentraNo1-Bold, line spacing about 1.2)
- text at x 68.6, y 47.3, w 9.5, h 8.5 [CentraNo1-Book, sans-serif, regular weight, regular case; font size 1.84% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: Accounting for grey / emissions of full / supply chain / 15% (15% in CentraNo1-Bold, line spacing about 1.2)
- text at x 4.2, y 6.6, w 32.3, h 5 [CentraNo1-Bold, geometric sans-serif, bold weight, regular case; font size 5% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: From capture to removal
- line at x 4.2, y 13.7, w 38.8, h 0.2 [#333333]: Thin horizontal title rule (Stroke about 1 px dark grey, straight, no caps)
- text at x 39.2, y 20.2, w 20.2, h 3 [CentraNo1-Bold, geometric sans-serif, bold weight, regular case; font size 2.96% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: CDR production efficiency
- text at x 15, y 26.8, w 7.2, h 2.4 [CentraNo1-Bold, geometric sans-serif, bold weight, regular case; font size 2.4% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: Availability
- text at x 33.6, y 30.4, w 8.1, h 2.4 [CentraNo1-Bold, geometric sans-serif, bold weight, regular case; font size 2.4% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: Performance
- text at x 52, y 30.8, w 5.8, h 2.4 [CentraNo1-Bold, geometric sans-serif, bold weight, regular case; font size 2.4% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: Recovery
- text at x 68.5, y 32.8, w 9.6, h 2.4 [CentraNo1-Bold, geometric sans-serif, bold weight, regular case; font size 2.4% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: Grey emissions
- text at x 5.3, y 76.8, w 9.3, h 5 [CentraNo1-Book, sans-serif, regular weight, regular case; font size 2.22% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: Nameplate CO2 / capture capacity (CO2 with subscript 2 at about 1.5 percent height, line spacing about 1.3)
- text at x 23.4, y 77, w 9.3, h 5 [CentraNo1-Book, sans-serif, regular weight, regular case; font size 2.22% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: Available CO2 / capture capacity (CO2 with subscript 2, line spacing about 1.3)
- text at x 43.9, y 76.8, w 5.1, h 5 [CentraNo1-Book, sans-serif, regular weight, regular case; font size 2.22% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: CO2 / captured (CO2 with subscript 2, line spacing about 1.3)
- text at x 62.8, y 76.6, w 3.6, h 5 [CentraNo1-Book, sans-serif, regular weight, regular case; font size 2.22% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: CO2 / stored (CO2 with subscript 2, line spacing about 1.3)
- text at x 79, y 76.8, w 5.6, h 5 [CentraNo1-Book, sans-serif, regular weight, regular case; font size 2.22% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: CDR / produced (line spacing about 1.3)
- shape at x 7.1, y 89.2, w 1.8, h 2.4 [#8EC7E9]: Legend swatch light blue (Square, square corners, no outline)
- text at x 9.9, y 89.5, w 7.2, h 2 [CentraNo1-Book, sans-serif, regular weight, regular case; font size 1.96% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: CO2 quantities (CO2 with subscript 2)
- shape at x 20.3, y 89.2, w 1.8, h 2.4 [#FFEB8A]: Legend swatch yellow (Square, square corners, no outline)
- text at x 23.1, y 89.5, w 10, h 2 [CentraNo1-Book, sans-serif, regular weight, regular case; font size 1.96% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: Corrections & losses
- shape at x 37, y 89.2, w 1.8, h 2.4 [#419FE8]: Legend swatch dark blue (Square, square corners, no outline)
- text at x 39.8, y 89.5, w 4.3, h 2 [CentraNo1-Book, sans-serif, regular weight, regular case; font size 1.96% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: Net CDR
- shape at x 87.1, y 52.7, w 9.7, h 17.3 [#FFFFFF]: Circular ring around certificate icon (Circle with 1 px blue stroke #419FE8, white fill, icon sits inside it)
- icon at x 88.7, y 55.7, w 7.1, h 12.6 [#000000]: Certificate document with rosette seal and check mark (Black line-art document with three text lines in the upper left, a rosette seal with ribbon tails at the lower right, and a blue check mark inside the seal; no fill, line weight about 2 px, unboxed)

**Measured from the file** (exact, read from the PDF rather than estimated; x, y, w, h as % of the slide; font size as % of the slide height)

- fill at x 0.0, y 0.0, w 100.0, h 100.0: #FFFFFF (covers the slide)
- fill at x 13.9, y 44.6, w 10.3, h 11.7: #FFFFFF
- fill at x 4.1, y 76.5, w 11.8, h 5.4: #FFFFFF
- fill at x 22.2, y 76.7, w 11.8, h 5.4: #FFFFFF
- fill at x 40.6, y 76.5, w 11.8, h 5.4: #FFFFFF
- fill at x 58.7, y 76.4, w 11.8, h 5.4: #FFFFFF
- fill at x 31.6, y 44.7, w 10.3, h 11.7: #FFFFFF
- fill at x 50.0, y 45.1, w 10.3, h 9.1: #FFFFFF
- fill at x 68.1, y 44.8, w 10.3, h 11.7: #FFFFFF
- fill at x 91.0, y 4.1, w 8.2, h 10.9: #FFFFFF
- fill at x 87.1, y 52.7, w 9.7, h 17.3: #FFFFFF
- image at x 4.5, y 26.2, w 82.5, h 49.1: 2201 by 736 pixels
- image at x 88.7, y 55.7, w 7.1, h 12.6: 117 by 116 pixels
- text at x 4.2, y 6.6, w 32.3, h 5.0 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 5.00; #000000]: From capture to removal
- text at x 39.2, y 20.2, w 20.2, h 3.0 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 2.96; #000000]: CDR production efficiency
- text at x 15.0, y 26.8, w 7.2, h 2.4 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 2.40; #000000]: Availability
- text at x 33.6, y 30.4, w 8.1, h 2.4 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 2.40; #000000]: Performance
- text at x 52.0, y 30.8, w 5.8, h 2.4 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 2.40; #000000]: Recovery
- text at x 68.5, y 32.8, w 9.6, h 2.4 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 2.40; #000000]: Grey emissions
- text at x 32.9, y 60.3, w 29.1, h 3.0 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 2.96; #000000]: Complete process is 3 party verified
- text at x 16.1, y 47.1, w 6.1, h 1.8 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 1.84; #000000]: Planned and
- text at x 32.1, y 47.2, w 9.5, h 1.8 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 1.84; #000000]: Wind, weather, and
- text at x 50.6, y 47.3, w 9.2, h 1.8 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 1.84; #000000]: CO extraction and
- text at x 68.6, y 47.3, w 9.5, h 1.8 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 1.84; #000000]: Accounting for grey
- text at x 16.5, y 49.4, w 5.4, h 1.8 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 1.84; #000000]: unplanned
- text at x 31.9, y 49.4, w 9.9, h 1.8 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 1.84; #000000]: sorbent degradation
- text at x 50.9, y 49.5, w 8.5, h 1.8 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 1.85; #000000]: purification losses
- text at x 69.5, y 49.5, w 7.8, h 1.8 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 1.85; #000000]: emissions of full
- text at x 16.7, y 51.6, w 4.8, h 1.8 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 1.85; #000000]: downtime
- text at x 35.3, y 51.7, w 2.8, h 1.8 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 1.84; #000000]: losses
- text at x 54.4, y 51.7, w 1.4, h 1.8 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 1.84; #000000]: 5%
- text at x 70.3, y 51.7, w 5.9, h 1.8 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 1.84; #000000]: supply chain
- text at x 18.1, y 53.8, w 1.9, h 1.8 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 1.84; #000000]: 10%
- text at x 33.7, y 53.9, w 1.8, h 1.8 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 1.84; #000000]: 0%
- text at x 35.5, y 53.9, w 4.3, h 1.8 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 1.84; #000000]: (average)
- text at x 72.4, y 54.0, w 1.8, h 1.8 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 1.84; #000000]: 15%
- text at x 49.7, y 60.2, w 1.1, h 2.0 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 1.98; #000000]: rd
- text at x 5.5, y 76.8, w 8.4, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.22; #000000]: Nameplate CO
- text at x 24.2, y 77.0, w 7.3, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.22; #000000]: Available CO
- text at x 45.4, y 76.8, w 1.9, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.22; #000000]: CO
- text at x 63.5, y 76.6, w 1.9, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.23; #000000]: CO
- text at x 80.6, y 76.8, w 2.8, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.22; #000000]: CDR
- text at x 62.8, y 79.3, w 3.6, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.22; #000000]: stored
- text at x 5.3, y 79.4, w 9.3, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.22; #000000]: capture capacity
- text at x 23.4, y 79.7, w 9.3, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.22; #000000]: capture capacity
- text at x 43.9, y 79.4, w 5.1, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.22; #000000]: captured
- text at x 79.0, y 79.4, w 5.6, h 2.2 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.22; #000000]: produced
- text at x 52.2, y 48.2, w 0.4, h 1.2 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 1.24; #000000]: 2
- text at x 9.9, y 89.5, w 7.2, h 2.0 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 1.96; #000000]: CO quantities
- text at x 23.1, y 89.5, w 10.0, h 2.0 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 1.96; #000000]: Corrections & losses
- text at x 39.8, y 89.5, w 4.3, h 2.0 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 1.96; #000000]: Net CDR
- text at x 65.4, y 77.8, w 0.6, h 1.5 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 1.49; #000000]: 2
- text at x 14.0, y 77.9, w 0.4, h 1.5 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 1.49; #000000]: 2
- text at x 31.6, y 78.1, w 0.4, h 1.5 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 1.49; #000000]: 2
- text at x 47.2, y 77.9, w 0.4, h 1.5 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 1.49; #000000]: 2
- text at x 11.6, y 90.5, w 0.4, h 1.3 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 1.29; #000000]: 2

### Slide 8

**Review notes**

- Review: Weaknesses remain: slide 1 shows '$1 tn' with no object, so the opener is unexplained, slide 7's waterfall uses tiny annotation text and slide 8 is a sparse diagram, and the ending on slide 10 is a modest chart with no closing statement.
- What would change the score: I would give slide 8 more substance or merge it with slide 7, and close with a statement slide that states the takeaway for the audience.

**Text**

Cost per ton / Total cost / CAPEX / OPEX / Overhead / COGS / Tons of CDR produced / Net CO2 stored, accounting for all losses and grey emissions

**Layout**

Single white slide with the title at top left, left-aligned over a short thin rule, and a two-column diagram below it split by a diagonal grey divider. The left column is a tree headed by a teal 'Total cost' box that branches into CAPEX, OPEX and Overhead, with a yellow COGS tag below CAPEX and OPEX. The right column is a tree headed by a light-blue 'Tons of CDR produced' box that branches into one icon and a text block. No slide number, footer or logo is visible.

**Visuals**

Diagram (the graphic is a raster image of 1437 by 700 pixels, placed without crop or border and spanning x 7.7 to 88.9 percent and y 10.9 to 81.3 percent). Left tree: teal box 'Total cost' with a line icon of a price tag with a blue leaf; grey elbow bracket lines (#BFBFBF, about 2 px) drop from the tag to three labels CAPEX, OPEX and Overhead. Under CAPEX is a black-outlined factory icon with a blue (#3A8FD9) window band and three small dots. Under OPEX is an icon of a rounded document with two lines and a blue gear. Under Overhead is a black-outlined pencil with a blue stripe. Below CAPEX and OPEX a grey bracket joins them to a yellow box labelled COGS. Right tree: light-blue box 'Tons of CDR produced' with a line icon of a stacked block with black dots and blue vertical lines; a grey bracket drops to a dome-shaped icon with a blue hexagon and a blue downward hollow arrow below it, next to the text 'Net CO2 stored, accounting for all losses and grey emissions'. A thick grey (#8C8C8C, about 4 px) diagonal line runs from upper right (about x 58.5 percent, y 25.8 percent) to lower left (about x 43.5 percent, y 84 percent), dividing the slide.

**Design**

Background: Solid white #FFFFFF.

**Elements and positions** (back to front; x, y, width, height as % of the slide; type, colour and alignment in brackets)

- title at x 4.2, y 6.6, w 16.1, h 5 [CentraNo1, Bold, sans-serif geometric; font size 5% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: Cost per ton (Single line, no italics, no capitals, no letter-spacing change.)
- line at x 4.2, y 13.8, w 20.2, h 0.1: Thin horizontal rule under the title (Stroke #4D4D4D, about 1 px, no fill, runs left under the title.)
- diagram at x 7.7, y 10.9, w 81.2, h 70.4: Raster image of the cost and output diagram, 1437 by 700 pixels, containing all icons, labels, boxes, brackets and the divider line (Placed image, not cropped, no border, sits behind the boxes and text drawn inside it; background of the image is white and blends with the slide.)
- shape at x 18.1, y 27.2, w 15.8, h 7.5: Teal filled rectangle behind the label 'Total cost' (Fill #A3CCC6, no border, square corners, no shadow.)
- shape at x 60.5, y 27.2, w 28.2, h 7.5: Light-blue filled rectangle behind the label 'Tons of CDR produced' (Fill #BBDDF0, thin grey outline #BFBFBF about 1 px, square corners, no shadow.)
- body at x 20.5, y 29, w 11, h 4 [Futura-like geometric sans, Bold; font size 3.3% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: Total cost (Sits centred inside the teal box.)
- body at x 62.2, y 29, w 24.8, h 4 [Futura-like geometric sans, Bold; font size 3.3% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: Tons of CDR produced (Sits centred inside the light-blue box.)
- icon at x 23, y 40.7, w 6.4, h 11.1 [#000000]: Price tag icon with a blue leaf (Black outline stroke about 2 px with a blue (#3A8FD9) leaf in the lower right.)
- icon at x 71.3, y 40.2, w 7.1, h 10 [#000000]: Stacked block icon with dots and blue vertical lines (Black outline stroke about 2 px, blue (#3A8FD9) vertical lines on the left face, black dots on the right face, two feet at the base.)
- line at x 12.4, y 56.4, w 26.6, h 2.2: Grey bracket above CAPEX, OPEX and Overhead (Stroke #BFBFBF about 2 px, elbow bracket with a centre tick under the tag icon and end ticks down to the labels.)
- line at x 61.2, y 56.4, w 26.3, h 2.2: Grey bracket above the CDR icon (Stroke #BFBFBF about 2 px, elbow bracket with centre tick and end ticks.)
- body at x 9, y 62.9, w 6.7, h 3.6 [Futura-like geometric sans, Bold; font size 3% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: CAPEX (Capitals.)
- body at x 22.9, y 62.9, w 5.5, h 3.6 [Futura-like geometric sans, Bold; font size 3% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: OPEX (Capitals.)
- body at x 34, y 62.9, w 9.9, h 3.6 [Futura-like geometric sans, Bold; font size 3% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: Overhead (Mixed case.)
- icon at x 9.7, y 68.8, w 5.1, h 7.3 [#000000]: Factory icon with a blue window band and three dots (Black outline about 2 px with blue (#3A8FD9) rectangle body outline.)
- icon at x 23.3, y 68.3, w 5.3, h 9.2 [#000000]: Document with lines and a blue gear icon for OPEX (Black outline about 2 px for the document, blue (#3A8FD9) gear at lower right.)
- icon at x 36.7, y 69, w 4.4, h 7.8 [#000000]: Pencil icon (Black outline about 2 px, blue (#3A8FD9) stripe along the body, diagonal from upper right to lower left.)
- line at x 12.4, y 81.3, w 13.2, h 3.8: Grey bracket joining CAPEX and OPEX to COGS (Stroke #BFBFBF about 2 px, open bracket with vertical ends rising to the labels and a horizontal segment on each side of the COGS box.)
- shape at x 14.4, y 81.9, w 9.9, h 6.3: Yellow filled rectangle behind the label 'COGS' (Fill #FDEB8C, no border, square corners, no shadow.)
- body at x 16.4, y 83.7, w 5.8, h 3.3 [Verdana, Bold, sans-serif; font size 3.33% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: COGS (Capitals.)
- icon at x 61.9, y 63.6, w 5.5, h 6.2 [#000000]: Dome icon with a blue hexagon (Black outline about 2 px, dome segmented into pentagon and hexagon panels, one blue (#3A8FD9) hexagon in the centre front.)
- icon at x 64.3, y 70.5, w 1.2, h 3.8 [#3A8FD9]: Downward hollow arrow (Blue (#3A8FD9) outline, hollow, pointing down, stroke about 2 px, sits under the dome icon.)
- body at x 69.6, y 61, w 17, h 17.1 [Futura-like geometric sans, Bold; font size 3% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: Net CO2 stored, accounting for all losses and grey emissions (Four lines: 'Net CO' with subscript '2' then ' stored,' / 'accounting for all' / 'losses and grey' / 'emissions'. Line spacing about 1.2. Subscript 2 is smaller and lowered.)
- shape at x 43.5, y 25.8, w 15, h 58.2: Thick grey diagonal divider line (Stroke #8C8C8C about 4 px, straight, no caps, runs from upper right (about 58.5 percent x, 25.8 percent y) to lower left (about 43.5 percent x, 84 percent y).)

**Measured from the file** (exact, read from the PDF rather than estimated; x, y, w, h as % of the slide; font size as % of the slide height)

- fill at x 0.0, y 0.0, w 100.0, h 100.0: #FFFFFF (covers the slide)
- fill at x 91.0, y 4.1, w 8.2, h 10.9: #FFFFFF
- fill at x 7.7, y 68.3, w 36.6, h 11.0: #FFFFFF
- fill at x 14.4, y 81.9, w 9.9, h 6.2: #FDEB8C
- fill at x 48.0, y 23.6, w 5.9, h 64.6: #FFFFFF
- fill at x 38.9, y 12.3, w 23.9, h 6.2: #FFFFFF
- image at x 7.7, y 10.9, w 81.2, h 70.4: 1437 by 700 pixels
- text at x 4.2, y 6.6, w 16.1, h 5.0 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 5.00; #000000]: Cost per ton
- text at x 16.4, y 83.7, w 5.8, h 3.3 [Verdana-Bold; font size 3.33; #000000]: COGS

### Slide 9

**Review notes**

- Worth studying: The photovoltaic cost curve, with phase labels across the top, turns a historical analogy into a visual argument about scale-up.
- Review: Slides 2, 5 and 9 are readable at keynote distance, each carrying one message with a clear hierarchy, and the full-bleed photo on slide 6 gives the room a pause.

**Text**

Technology scale-up has to overcome a cost mountain / Indicative cost evolution of photovoltaic electricity production / R&D / Demonstration / Deployment / Maturation / Cost estimates / Achieved costs / 1960s – 1980s / 1980s – 2000s / 1950s / Today / Source: Bell laboratories 1954, indicative cost estimates, curve based on Yeh and Rubin: Uncertainties in Technology Experience Curves for Energy-Economic Models (2011)

**Layout**

Single slide with a title at top left, a thin black rule beneath it, and a subtitle with a solar panel icon at upper right of the subtitle. Below is a full-width row of four equal-width columns (R&D, Demonstration, Deployment, Maturation) with thin white gutters, spanning roughly x 4 to 96 and y 30 to 90, each column with its header centred at the top. A black curve runs across the columns with white dots marking the periods. The source line sits bottom left at about y 95. No slide number is visible. Margins are roughly 4 percent on the left and right.

**Visuals**

Diagram over four columns: a black hill-shaped curve (cost mountain) starting low in the R&D column near 1950s, rising to a peak in the Demonstration column at 1960s – 1980s, then falling through Deployment at 1980s – 2000s and ending low in Maturation at Today. Four white filled circular markers (about 1.8 by 3.2 percent) sit on the curve at the 1950s, 1960s – 1980s, 1980s – 2000s and Today points. A horizontal black double-headed arrow across the Demonstration, Deployment and Maturation columns at about y 38.5 has the label Achieved costs interrupted by a light-blue box in the middle; the left arrowhead points left and the right arrowhead points right. The 'Cost estimates' label sits above the R&D column. The icon is a line-drawn photovoltaic solar panel: a trapezoid black outline with a cross-shaped grid of four cells, on a thin blue sun arc with short radiating dashes, drawn in black and light blue on a white background with no fill. No values, axes, legend or units are printed.

**Design**

Background: Solid white #FFFFFF. White background. Title in bold geometric sans-serif (CentraNo1 Bold style) in black #000000, about 5 percent of slide height. Subtitle and body labels in CentraNo1 Book regular sans-serif in black #000000, about 3 percent of slide height. Column headers in bold sans-serif black #000000 about 2.6 percent. Source line in regular sans-serif grey #808080 about 1.8 percent. Column fills step from light grey #E9E9E9 through pale blue #D1E9F6 and mid blue #8DC8E8 to strong blue #419FE7 for Maturation. Accent blue #419FE7 in the icon and the Maturation column. Rules and curve are thin black lines, about 0.1 to 0.2 percent of slide height thick. Shapes are square-cornered rectangles with no shadows or gradients.

**Elements and positions** (back to front; x, y, width, height as % of the slide; type, colour and alignment in brackets)

- shape at x 4, y 30.3, w 22.8, h 59.5 [#E9E9E9]: Column fill R&D, light grey panel (Solid fill, square corners, no outline, no shadow)
- shape at x 27.1, y 30.3, w 22.9, h 59.5 [#D1E9F6]: Column fill Demonstration, pale blue panel (Solid fill, square corners, no outline, no shadow)
- shape at x 50.2, y 30.3, w 22.8, h 59.5 [#8DC8E8]: Column fill Deployment, mid blue panel (Solid fill, square corners, no outline, no shadow)
- shape at x 73.3, y 30.3, w 22.8, h 59.5 [#419FE7]: Column fill Maturation, strong blue panel (Solid fill, square corners, no outline, no shadow)
- shape at x 55, y 37.3, w 13.3, h 3.2 [#8DC8E8]: Light blue box masking the arrow line behind the Achieved costs label (Solid fill matching the Deployment column, no outline)
- line at x 30.9, y 38.1, w 61.4, h 1.1 [#000000]: Horizontal double-headed arrow with label gap, Achieved costs (Black line about 0.1 percent of slide height thick, left arrowhead at x 31 pointing left, right arrowhead at x 92 pointing right, interrupted by the Achieved costs label box)
- line at x 14.6, y 48.7, w 68.4, h 32.6 [#000000]: Black cost-mountain curve (Smooth single black stroke about 0.2 percent of slide height thick, arc peaking near x 35 y 49, descending to x 83 y 81, open ended at both ends, drawn over the column fills)
- shape at x 14.7, y 58.8, w 3, h 4.8 [#FFFFFF]: White circular marker for 1950s point (Filled white circle with no outline, sits on the curve)
- shape at x 33.9, y 46.9, w 2.9, h 4.6 [#FFFFFF]: White circular marker for 1960s – 1980s peak point (Filled white circle with no outline, sits on the curve at the peak)
- shape at x 59.8, y 60.3, w 3.4, h 5.4 [#FFFFFF]: White circular marker for 1980s – 2000s point (Filled white circle with no outline, sits on the curve)
- shape at x 79.6, y 77.9, w 2.9, h 4.6 [#FFFFFF]: White circular marker for Today point (Filled white circle with no outline, sits on the curve)
- shape at x 91, y 4.1, w 8.2, h 10.9 [#FFFFFF]: White rectangle at upper right, no visible content (Solid white fill, no outline, blends into the white background)
- line at x 4.2, y 13.6, w 72, h 0.2 [#000000]: Thin black rule under the title (Hairline black stroke, square ends, spanning from x 4.2 to 76.2)
- line at x 3.9, y 27.2, w 92.2, h 0.2 [#000000]: Thin black rule under the subtitle (Hairline black stroke, square ends, spanning from x 3.9 to 96.1)
- icon at x 54.1, y 10.6, w 12.1, h 20.6 [#419FE7]: Photovoltaic solar panel icon with sun arc (Image 165 by 158 pixels; line icon drawn in black panel outline with a four-cell grid and a light-blue sun arc with radiating dashes, transparent background, no shadow)
- title at x 4.2, y 6.6, w 70.7, h 5 [CentraNo1 Bold, sans-serif, bold weight, no italics, no capitals, normal letter-spacing; font size 5% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: Technology scale-up has to overcome a cost mountain
- subtitle at x 3.9, y 23.3, w 52.7, h 3.3 [CentraNo1 Book, sans-serif, regular weight, no italics, no capitals, normal letter-spacing; font size 3.33% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: Indicative cost evolution of photovoltaic electricity production
- body at x 13.9, y 32, w 3.4, h 2.6 [CentraNo1 Bold, sans-serif, bold weight, no italics, no capitals, normal letter-spacing; font size 2.6% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: R&D
- body at x 33.4, y 32, w 10.2, h 2.6 [CentraNo1 Bold, sans-serif, bold weight, no italics, no capitals, normal letter-spacing; font size 2.6% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: Demonstration
- body at x 57.4, y 32, w 8.5, h 2.6 [CentraNo1 Bold, sans-serif, bold weight, no italics, no capitals, normal letter-spacing; font size 2.6% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: Deployment
- body at x 80.9, y 32, w 7.6, h 2.6 [CentraNo1 Bold, sans-serif, bold weight, no italics, no capitals, normal letter-spacing; font size 2.6% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: Maturation
- body at x 10.8, y 37.7, w 9.6, h 2.6 [CentraNo1 Book, sans-serif, regular weight, no italics, no capitals, normal letter-spacing; font size 2.6% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: Cost estimates
- body at x 56.7, y 37.7, w 9.9, h 2.6 [CentraNo1 Book, sans-serif, regular weight, no italics, no capitals, normal letter-spacing; font size 2.6% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: Achieved costs
- body at x 30.2, y 44, w 10.4, h 3 [CentraNo1 Book, sans-serif, regular weight, no italics, no capitals, normal letter-spacing; font size 2.96% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: 1960s – 1980s
- body at x 56.4, y 55.5, w 10.9, h 3 [CentraNo1 Book, sans-serif, regular weight, no italics, no capitals, normal letter-spacing; font size 2.96% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: 1980s – 2000s
- body at x 10.5, y 60.6, w 4.2, h 3 [CentraNo1 Book, sans-serif, regular weight, no italics, no capitals, normal letter-spacing; font size 2.96% of slide height; #000000; right aligned]: 1950s
- body at x 82.2, y 74.9, w 4.6, h 3 [CentraNo1 Book, sans-serif, regular weight, no italics, no capitals, normal letter-spacing; font size 2.96% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: Today
- caption at x 2.3, y 95.1, w 79.9, h 1.8 [CentraNo1 Book, sans-serif, regular weight, no italics, no capitals, normal letter-spacing; font size 1.84% of slide height; #808080; left aligned]: Source: Bell laboratories 1954, indicative cost estimates, curve based on Yeh and Rubin: Uncertainties in Technology Experience Curves for Energy-Economic Models (2011)

**Measured from the file** (exact, read from the PDF rather than estimated; x, y, w, h as % of the slide; font size as % of the slide height)

- fill at x 0.0, y 0.0, w 100.0, h 100.0: #FFFFFF (covers the slide)
- fill at x 4.0, y 30.3, w 22.8, h 59.5: #E9E9E9
- fill at x 27.1, y 30.3, w 22.9, h 59.5: #D1E9F6
- fill at x 50.2, y 30.3, w 22.8, h 59.5: #8DC8E8
- fill at x 73.3, y 30.3, w 22.8, h 59.5: #419FE7
- fill at x 91.0, y 4.1, w 8.2, h 10.9: #FFFFFF
- fill at x 30.9, y 38.1, w 61.4, h 1.1: #000000
- fill at x 55.0, y 37.3, w 13.3, h 3.2: #8DC8E8
- image at x 54.1, y 10.6, w 12.1, h 20.6: 165 by 158 pixels
- text at x 4.2, y 6.6, w 70.7, h 5.0 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 5.00; #000000]: Technology scale-up has to overcome a cost mountain
- text at x 3.9, y 23.3, w 52.7, h 3.3 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 3.33; #000000]: Indicative cost evolution of photovoltaic electricity production
- text at x 13.9, y 32.0, w 3.4, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 2.60; #000000]: R&D
- text at x 33.4, y 32.0, w 10.2, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 2.60; #000000]: Demonstration
- text at x 57.4, y 32.0, w 8.5, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 2.60; #000000]: Deployment
- text at x 80.9, y 32.0, w 7.6, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 2.60; #000000]: Maturation
- text at x 10.8, y 37.7, w 9.6, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.60; #000000]: Cost estimates
- text at x 56.7, y 37.7, w 9.9, h 2.6 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.60; #000000]: Achieved costs
- text at x 30.2, y 44.0, w 10.4, h 3.0 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.96; #000000]: 1960s – 1980s
- text at x 56.4, y 55.5, w 10.9, h 3.0 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.96; #000000]: 1980s – 2000s
- text at x 10.5, y 60.6, w 4.2, h 3.0 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.96; #000000]: 1950s
- text at x 82.2, y 74.9, w 4.6, h 3.0 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.96; #000000]: Today
- text at x 2.3, y 95.1, w 79.9, h 1.8 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 1.84; #808080]: Source: Bell laboratories 1954, indicative cost estimates, curve based on Yeh and Rubin: Uncertainties in Technology Experience Curves for Energy-Economic Models (2011)

### Slide 10

**Review notes**

- Review: Weaknesses remain: slide 1 shows '$1 tn' with no object, so the opener is unexplained, slide 7's waterfall uses tiny annotation text and slide 8 is a sparse diagram, and the ending on slide 10 is a modest chart with no closing statement.
- Suggested repair: Say what the $1 tn is on slide 1, enlarge the annotations on slide 7, and make slide 10 land the 40 percent versus 20 percent point, which is currently confusing against the donut labels.

**Text**

2023 indicative portfolio / In collaboration with / Bain & Company / WORLD ECONOMIC FORUM / The Voluntary Carbon Market: Climate Finance at an Inflection Point / BRIEFING PAPER / JANUARY 2023 / 40% / 20% / 40% / Nature-based avoidance / Nature-based removal / Engineered removal / 20% / of engineered removals / Net-zero aligned portfolios / suggest ~40% engineered CDR by / 2030 / Source: Based on World Economic Forum - The Voluntary Carbon Market: Climate Finance at an Inflection Point, January 2023

**Layout**

Three-column arrangement below a title at top left with a thin horizontal rule under it: a book-cover photo in the left column, a donut chart with its legend in the centre column, and a large callout figure with body text in the right column. Title left-aligned at about 4.3% from the left edge and 6.6% from the top; the rule runs from about 4.2% to 55% of the width at about 13.8% height. The source line sits at the bottom left at about 2.3% from the left and 95% from the top. No slide number is shown.

**Visuals**

Two visuals. (1) Photograph of a book cover, boxed, not cropped, shown at about 23.4% by 58.9% of the slide with no border or shadow. The subject is a young green seedling with several leaves growing out of a pile of gold coins resting on brown soil. The background is soft green bokeh, and the lower part is warm brown. The cover carries white text and the WEF logo. Lighting is soft and natural, dominant colours are green, gold and brown, and the image is full-colour and unframed. (2) Donut chart with no axes, titled by the slide heading. Outer ring about 26% of slide width, centred near 45% across and 56% down, with an inner hole about half the outer diameter. Series, all shown as percentage shares summing to 100%: Nature-based avoidance 40% in #67AEA2 (upper-left segment, label 40% in #404040), Nature-based removal 40% in #027864 (lower segment, label 40% in #404040), Engineered removal 20% in #419FE7 (right segment, label 20% in #404040). Segments are separated by thin white gaps. Legend below the chart lists the three series with colour swatches in the order avoidance, removal, engineered. Highlighted point: the 20% engineered removal segment is linked by a black leader line to the right-hand callout.

**Design**

Background: Solid white #FFFFFF.

**Elements and positions** (back to front; x, y, width, height as % of the slide; type, colour and alignment in brackets)

- shape at x 0, y 0, w 100, h 100 [#FFFFFF]: Full-slide white background fill (Covers the whole slide, no border)
- photo at x 4.7, y 26.5, w 23.4, h 58.9: Book cover image: green seedling growing from a pile of gold coins on brown soil, with white cover text reading In collaboration with Bain & Company, WORLD ECONOMIC FORUM, The Voluntary Carbon Market: Climate Finance at an Inflection Point, BRIEFING PAPER, JANUARY 2023 (Placed image 592 by 838 pixels, not cropped, no border, no shadow, no overlay)
- chart at x 31.8, y 27.9, w 31, h 55.7 [#027864]: Donut chart with three segments: Nature-based avoidance 40% (#67AEA2), Nature-based removal 40% (#027864), Engineered removal 20% (#419FE7) (Outer ring diameter about 26% of slide width, inner hole about half the diameter, white 1px separators between segments, no axes, no chart title beyond the slide heading)
- text at x 41.5, y 34.1, w 3.5, h 3 [CentraNo1-Book, regular weight; font size 2.96% of slide height; #404040; center aligned]: 40% (Data label on the Nature-based avoidance segment)
- text at x 41.1, y 71, w 3.4, h 3 [CentraNo1-Book, regular weight; font size 2.96% of slide height; #404040; center aligned]: 40% (Data label on the Nature-based removal segment)
- text at x 55.7, y 53, w 3.3, h 3 [CentraNo1-Book, regular weight; font size 2.96% of slide height; #404040; center aligned]: 20% (Data label on the Engineered removal segment)
- line at x 55.7, y 40.6, w 11.1, h 27.1 [#000000]: Leader line from the engineered removal segment to the callout, consisting of a horizontal stub and a vertical bracket (Black stroke about 2px wide; horizontal stub at about 54% down from x 60.6% to 66.8%; vertical bar at about 66.8% across from 40.6% to 67.7% down)
- shape at x 39.6, y 83.2, w 1.9, h 2.3 [#67AEA2]: Legend swatch for Nature-based avoidance (Filled square, no outline)
- text at x 41.7, y 83.4, w 12.8, h 2 [CentraNo1-Book, regular weight; font size 2.04% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: Nature-based avoidance (Legend label)
- shape at x 39.6, y 86.6, w 1.9, h 2.3 [#027864]: Legend swatch for Nature-based removal (Filled square, no outline)
- text at x 41.7, y 86.9, w 11.7, h 2 [CentraNo1-Book, regular weight; font size 2.04% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: Nature-based removal (Legend label)
- shape at x 39.6, y 90, w 1.9, h 2.3 [#419FE7]: Legend swatch for Engineered removal (Filled square, no outline)
- text at x 41.7, y 90.3, w 10.4, h 2 [CentraNo1-Book, regular weight; font size 2.04% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: Engineered removal (Legend label)
- line at x 4.2, y 13.6, w 50.7, h 0.2 [#404040]: Thin horizontal rule under the title (Stroke about 1px, dark grey, straight, no caps)
- title at x 4.3, y 6.6, w 32.2, h 5 [CentraNo1-Bold, bold, sentence case, no letter-spacing; font size 5% of slide height; #000000; left aligned]: 2023 indicative portfolio (Single line)
- text at x 71.3, y 34.1, w 22.1, h 17.8 [Georgia-Bold, bold, serif, no letter-spacing; font size 17.78% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: 20% (Large callout figure)
- text at x 72.1, y 54.4, w 22.2, h 3.7 [CentraNo1-Book, regular weight; font size 3.71% of slide height; #000000; center aligned]: of engineered removals (Callout caption under the figure)
- text at x 70.5, y 62.4, w 25.7, h 10.1 [CentraNo1-Book, regular weight; font size 2.96% of slide height; #494949; left aligned]: Net-zero aligned portfolios / suggest ~40% engineered CDR by / 2030 (Three lines, line spacing about 3.5% of slide height)
- text at x 2.3, y 95.1, w 59.1, h 1.8 [CentraNo1-Book, regular weight; font size 1.84% of slide height; #808080; left aligned]: Source: Based on World Economic Forum - The Voluntary Carbon Market: Climate Finance at an Inflection Point, January 2023 (Source line, footer)

**Measured from the file** (exact, read from the PDF rather than estimated; x, y, w, h as % of the slide; font size as % of the slide height)

- fill at x 0.0, y 0.0, w 100.0, h 100.0: #FFFFFF (covers the slide)
- fill at x 31.8, y 53.6, w 26.2, h 29.7: #027864
- fill at x 31.9, y 27.9, w 26.5, h 25.9: #67AEA2
- fill at x 52.2, y 39.2, w 9.7, h 30.4: #419FE7
- fill at x 91.0, y 4.1, w 8.2, h 10.9: #FFFFFF
- image at x 4.7, y 26.5, w 23.4, h 58.9: 592 by 838 pixels
- text at x 4.3, y 6.6, w 32.2, h 5.0 [CentraNo1-Bold; font size 5.00; #000000]: 2023 indicative portfolio
- text at x 71.3, y 34.1, w 22.1, h 17.8 [Georgia-Bold; font size 17.78; #000000]: 20%
- text at x 41.5, y 34.1, w 3.5, h 3.0 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.96; #404040]: 40%
- text at x 72.1, y 54.4, w 22.2, h 3.7 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 3.71; #000000]: of engineered removals
- text at x 55.7, y 53.0, w 3.3, h 3.0 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.96; #404040]: 20%
- text at x 70.5, y 62.4, w 20.8, h 3.0 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.96; #494949]: Net-zero aligned portfolios
- text at x 70.5, y 65.9, w 25.7, h 3.0 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.96; #494949]: suggest ~40% engineered CDR by
- text at x 70.5, y 69.5, w 3.9, h 3.0 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.96; #494949]: 2030
- text at x 41.1, y 71.0, w 3.4, h 3.0 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.96; #404040]: 40%
- text at x 41.7, y 83.4, w 12.8, h 2.0 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.04; #000000]: Nature-based avoidance
- text at x 41.7, y 86.9, w 11.7, h 2.0 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.04; #000000]: Nature-based removal
- text at x 41.7, y 90.3, w 10.4, h 2.0 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 2.04; #000000]: Engineered removal
- text at x 2.3, y 95.1, w 59.1, h 1.8 [CentraNo1-Book; font size 1.84; #808080]: Source: Based on World Economic Forum - The Voluntary Carbon Market: Climate Finance at an Inflection Point, January 2023
